A BG track comes across a curve of radius 1000 m. The equilibrium cant is provided considering a speed of 90 km/hr. Calculate the maximum and minimum permissible speeds on the track if the limiting values of cant deficiency and cant excess are 75 mm each.
15 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
With G = 1750 mm, the equilibrium cant for 90 km/h on a 1000 m curve is e = GV²/127R = 111.6 mm; maximum permissible speed (cant + 75 mm deficiency) ≈ 116.4 km/h, and minimum permissible speed (cant − 75 mm excess) ≈ 51.5 km/h.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Method: the cant equation e = GV²/(127R) gives the equilibrium cant; the maximum speed is the one whose theoretical cant equals actual cant plus cant deficiency, and the minimum speed is the one whose theoretical cant equals actual cant minus cant excess.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given: broad gauge, R = 1000 m, equilibrium speed 90 km/h, cant deficiency Cd = 75 mm, cant excess Cex = 75 mm. Assumed: for BG (1676 mm gauge) the distance between rail-head centres G is taken as 1750 mm in the cant formula.
Step 1: Equilibrium cant
- e = G V²/(127 R) = 1750 × 90²/(127 × 1000)
- e = 1750 × 8100/127000 = 111.61 mm, say 111.6 mm
Step 2: Maximum permissible speed
- Theoretical cant at Vmax = e + Cd = 111.61 + 75 = 186.61 mm
- Vmax = √[127 R (e + Cd)/G] = √(127 × 1000 × 186.61/1750)
- Vmax = √13542.7 = 116.4 km/h
- Check: √(127/1750) = 0.2694, so Vmax = 0.2694 × √(186.61 × 1000) = 116.4 km/h, which agrees
Step 3: Minimum permissible speed
- Theoretical cant at Vmin = e − Cex = 111.61 − 75 = 36.61 mm
- Vmin = √[127 R (e − Cex)/G] = √(127 × 1000 × 36.61/1750)
- Vmin = √2657.1 = 51.5 km/h
Conclusion
Maximum permissible speed ≈ 116.4 km/h and minimum ≈ 51.5 km/h. Check: substituting 116.4 km/h back into GV²/127R gives 186.6 mm = 111.6 + 75.
Examples and data to cite
- Cant excess matters for slow goods trains, which run below the equilibrium speed and load the inner rail; cant deficiency matters for fast passenger trains, which run above it and load the outer rail.
- If G were taken as the gauge itself (1676 mm), e = 106.9 mm and the limits become about 117.4 km/h and 49.2 km/h, so the stated value of G should always be shown in the answer.
Facts to remember
- Cant e = G V²/(127 R), G in mm, V in km/h, R in m.
- Cant deficiency = theoretical cant for the maximum speed − actual cant.
- Cant excess = actual cant − theoretical cant for the slowest (booked) speed.
- G = 1750 mm is the usual value for BG (1676 mm gauge) in the cant formula.