With respect to the chemical admixtures that are added to concrete, briefly differentiate ‘Accelerators’ from ‘Retarders’, and also explain how they modify the properties of concrete.
10 marks · directive: Differentiate
The core of a good answer
Accelerators speed up the hydration of cement so that concrete sets and gains strength earlier, while retarders slow down hydration so that concrete stays plastic longer; accelerators suit cold weather, retarders suit hot weather, mass concrete and large or difficult pours that must not partly set before the pour is finished.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should first contrast the two admixture types (action, chemicals, uses), then explain their effects on fresh and hardened properties such as setting time, workability, heat, early and later strength, shrinkage and durability.
Answer outline
Introduction
Chemical admixtures are added in small quantities (normally less than 5 per cent by mass of cement) to modify the properties of concrete. In India they must comply with IS 9103, which covers accelerating, retarding, water-reducing, air-entraining and superplasticising admixtures.
Differences
- Function: an accelerating admixture speeds up the hydration of cement, so setting and early strength gain come sooner; a retarding admixture delays the setting of cement (IS 9103 definitions).
- Typical chemicals: accelerators such as calcium chloride, calcium nitrate and sodium nitrate; retarders such as sugar, sodium gluconate, citric acid and tartaric acid.
- Site use: accelerators are especially useful in cold weather, when low temperatures slow hydration; retarders are widely used in hot-weather concreting and mass concrete, and in large or difficult pours where partial setting before the pour is complete is undesirable.
- Heat: an accelerator brings the heat of hydration forward; a retarder spreads it over a longer period, which helps limit overheating from the exothermic setting of cement.
Effect of accelerators on concrete
- Earlier initial setting and faster early hardening, so formwork can be stripped sooner and the concrete gains strength before it is exposed to cold.
- Shorter working time after mixing.
- Chloride accelerators bring chloride ions that corrode steel reinforcement, so calcium chloride should not be used in reinforced concrete; IS 456 Table 7 limits the total acid-soluble chloride in concrete, more strictly for prestressed than for reinforced concrete.
Effect of retarders on concrete
- Concrete stays workable for longer, so successive layers of a large pour can be placed and compacted before the earlier layer sets, avoiding cold joints.
- Setting and early strength gain are delayed.
- In hot weather the slower reaction helps control the rate of heat release and the loss of workability during transport and placing.
- Because a small change in dose of a strong retarder such as sugar has a large effect, dosage must be controlled and checked by trial mixes.
Conclusion
Accelerators and retarders are the two ends of setting time control; the right choice depends on temperature, size and duration of the pour, and the presence of reinforcement.
Examples and data to cite
- IS 9103:1999 'Concrete admixtures: specification' (Bureau of Indian Standards) classifies accelerating, retarding, water-reducing, air-entraining and superplasticising admixtures; IS 456:2000 clause 5.5.1 requires admixtures to comply with it.
- IS 456:2000 Table 7 limits the total acid-soluble chloride content in concrete, which restricts the use of calcium chloride accelerators in reinforced and prestressed concrete.
Facts to remember
- Calcium chloride is the classic accelerator; chloride ions corrode reinforcing steel.
- Sugar, sodium gluconate, citric acid and tartaric acid are typical retarders.
- Admixture dosages are normally less than 5 per cent by mass of cement.
- Accelerators suit cold weather; retarders suit hot weather and mass concrete.