What is the creep for hardened concrete ? With a neat sketch, draw the time-versus-deformation diagram of hardened concrete.
10 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Creep is the gradual increase in strain of hardened concrete with time under a sustained stress, over and above the instantaneous elastic strain; the time-deformation diagram shows an initial elastic strain on loading, creep increasing at a decreasing rate, an immediate elastic recovery on unloading, a slower creep recovery and a permanent irrecoverable creep strain.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define creep, explain its causes and factors, and draw the standard strain-time diagram for loading and unloading (with shrinkage separated if a drying specimen is shown). Mention its effects and the IS 456 creep coefficients.
Answer outline
Introduction
Concrete under a constant load keeps deforming for years. Over a structure's life creep may reach 3 to 6 times the initial elastic strain, so it must be considered in deflection, prestress loss and long-term behaviour.
Definition and mechanism
- Creep: time-dependent increase in strain under sustained constant stress.
- Originates in the calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H) of the hardened cement paste, through slips caused by bond ruptures with bond restoration at adjacent sites; changes in pore water content strongly influence it.
- Basic creep occurs at constant water content; drying creep (the Pickett effect) is the extra creep when the concrete dries while loaded.
Time-deformation diagram (to sketch)
- X axis: time since loading; Y axis: strain (deformation).
- At t0 load applied: a vertical jump equal to the instantaneous elastic strain.
- Under sustained load: the curve keeps rising at a decreasing rate (creep strain); multi-year creep grows roughly logarithmically with time, with no final asymptote.
- At unloading time t1: an immediate drop (elastic recovery).
- After unloading: a further gradual drop (creep recovery), which is only partial because of ageing.
- The curve levels off above zero: residual deformation is the irreversible creep.
- For a drying specimen, shrinkage strain of an unloaded companion specimen is drawn as a separate lower curve; total strain = elastic + creep + shrinkage.
Factors affecting creep
- Creep occurs at all stress levels and, within the service range and at constant pore water content, is roughly proportional to stress.
- Age at loading has a strong effect even after many years: concrete loaded young creeps more (IS 456 creep coefficient 2.2 at 7 days against 1.1 at 1 year).
- Drying while loaded, small member thickness and higher temperature increase creep.
- Very low water-cement ratios in high-strength concrete bring self-desiccation, which acts like drying shrinkage.
Effects
- Increase in long-term deflection; underestimated multi-decade creep has caused excessive deflection and cracking in large-span bridges.
- Major loss of prestress in prestressed concrete (with shrinkage).
- Differential shortening of columns, a particular concern in very tall buildings.
- Relaxation of stresses caused by imposed deformations that are held over time.
Conclusion
Creep is a slow, partly recoverable deformation under sustained load; the strain-time sketch must show elastic strain, creep, elastic recovery, creep recovery and residual creep.
Examples and data to cite
- IS 456:2000 clause 6.2.5.1 gives ultimate creep coefficients of 2.2 for loading at 7 days, 1.6 at 28 days and 1.1 at 1 year.
- Long-term deflection calculations in IS 456 Annex C use an effective modulus Ece = Ec/(1 + θ), where θ is the creep coefficient.
Facts to remember
- Creep coefficient θ = creep strain/instantaneous elastic strain.
- Effective modulus of elasticity = Ec/(1 + θ).
- Creep continues for many years at a reducing rate, roughly logarithmic in time.
- After unloading, creep recovery is only partial because of ageing, so part of the creep is permanent.