A catchment has six rain gauge stations. The annual rainfall recorded by the gauges in a year is as follows :
Station | A | B | C | D | E | F
Rainfall (cm) | 82.7 | 102.9 | 180.3 | 110.3 | 95.8 | 136.70
(i) Determine the standard error in the estimation of mean rainfall in the existing set of rain gauges.
(ii) For a 10% error in the estimation of mean rainfall, calculate the optimum number of rain gauge stations in the catchment.
10 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
Mean rainfall = 118.12 cm, standard deviation (n − 1) = 35.38 cm, Cv = 29.95%; (i) the percentage standard error with 6 gauges is ε = Cv/√N = 12.23%; (ii) for ε = 10%, N = (Cv/ε)² = 8.97, so 9 gauges are needed, i.e. 3 more stations.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
This is the standard statistical method for the adequacy of a rain gauge network: compute the coefficient of variation of the station rainfalls, use ε = Cv/√N for the existing error, and invert it for the optimum number of gauges at the allowable error.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given N = 6 stations with annual rainfalls 82.7, 102.9, 180.3, 110.3, 95.8 and 136.70 cm. Use the sample standard deviation with (N − 1).
Step 1: Mean
- ΣP = 82.7 + 102.9 + 180.3 + 110.3 + 95.8 + 136.7 = 708.7 cm
- P̄ = 708.7/6 = 118.12 cm
Step 2: Standard deviation
- σ(n−1) = √[Σ(P − P̄)²/(N − 1)]
- Σ(P − P̄)² = 6257.13 cm², so σ = √(6257.13/5) = 35.38 cm
Step 3: Coefficient of variation
- Cv = 100 σ/P̄ = 100 × 35.38/118.12 = 29.95%
Step 4: (i) Standard error of the mean with existing gauges
- ε = Cv/√N = 29.95/√6 = 12.23%
- In absolute terms, σ/√N = 35.38/2.449 = 14.44 cm on a mean of 118.12 cm
Step 5: (ii) Optimum number for 10% error
- N = (Cv/ε)² = (29.95/10)² = 8.97
- Adopt N = 9 gauges, so 9 − 6 = 3 additional stations are required
Conclusion
The present network gives the mean with about 12.2% error; nine gauges bring it within 10%. Check: 29.95/√9 = 9.98% ≤ 10%. The new gauges should be placed in the parts of the catchment that are under-represented, especially where the high reading at C suggests large spatial variation.
Examples and data to cite
- Station C (180.3 cm) is far above the mean, which is what drives the high Cv of about 30%.
Facts to remember
- Cv = 100 σ(n−1)/P̄ is computed with the sample standard deviation (divisor N − 1).
- Percentage error in the mean: ε = Cv/√N; optimum gauges N = (Cv/ε)².
- The allowable error ε is fixed by the designer; here the question sets it at 10%.
- The answer N is always rounded up to the next whole number.