How does the variation of sewage flow affect its velocity in a circular sewer ?
8 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Because sewage flow varies through the day and over the design period, a circular sewer usually runs partly full; by Manning's equation the velocity depends on the hydraulic mean depth, so it equals the full-bore velocity at half depth, peaks at about 1.14 V_full at 0.81 depth, but falls to about 0.62 V_full at 0.2 depth, which is why sewers must be checked for self-cleansing velocity at minimum flow.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain partial flow hydraulics in circular sections, give the proportionate velocity and discharge relations, and bring out the design consequences: deposition at low flow, scouring at high flow and the choice of depth ratio.
Answer outline
Introduction
Sewage flow varies through the day with daily routines (flow peaking) and grows over the design period; the sewer must carry the peak and still keep solids moving at low flow.
Partial flow hydraulics
- Manning: V = (1/n) R^(2/3) S^(1/2), R = A/P; for constant n and S, v/V_full = (r/R_full)^(2/3); a full pipe has R = D/4.
- For depth ratio d/D, central angle θ = 2 cos⁻¹(1 − 2d/D); a/A = (θ − sin θ)/(2π); r/R_full = (θ − sin θ)/θ.
- d/D = 0.2: v/V = 0.62, q/Q = 0.09; 0.3: 0.78, 0.20; 0.5: 1.00, 0.50; 0.7: 1.12, 0.84; 0.8: 1.14, 0.98.
- Velocity is maximum (1.14 V_full) at d/D ≈ 0.81; discharge is maximum (1.076 Q_full) at d/D ≈ 0.94.
Effect of low flow
- At night and in the early years the depth ratio is small, the hydraulic mean depth and the velocity drop sharply (0.62 V_full at 0.2 depth), turbulence falls and solids settle in the sewer.
- Sulphate-reducing bacteria in sewer mains form sulphides; H₂S released into the sewer atmosphere is oxidised to sulphuric acid, which causes crown corrosion of concrete sewers.
- So gradients are chosen to give velocities with enough turbulence to limit settling, and this is checked at low flow, not only at design flow.
Effect of high flow
- Above about 0.8 depth, extra flow gives little extra velocity (1.12 V_full at 0.7 depth, 1.14 at 0.8, 1.10 at 0.94) and the sewer approaches running full.
- Discharge peaks at about 1.076 Q_full at 0.94 depth and falls slightly as the pipe fills, because the wetted perimeter grows faster than the area near the crown.
Design responses
- Choose the slope so that adequate velocity is attained at low flow, and the size so that the peak flow is carried without running full.
- Keep air space above the flow; sewer gases are vented through manholes and vent pipes.
- Note: Manning's n varies with depth in partly full circular pipes (Camp's curves), so constant-n proportional values are an approximation.
Conclusion
Flow variation changes the depth, and through the hydraulic mean depth the velocity; the sewer is safe only if it is self-cleansing at minimum flow and free-flowing at peak.
Examples and data to cite
- At half depth a circular sewer carries half the full discharge at the full-bore velocity, since R at half depth equals R full (D/4).
Facts to remember
- Hydraulic mean depth of a full circular pipe = D/4, same as at half depth.
- Maximum velocity at d/D ≈ 0.81 (≈ 1.14 V_full); maximum discharge at d/D ≈ 0.94 (≈ 1.076 Q_full).
- Sulphides formed by sulphate-reducing bacteria in sewers cause crown corrosion of concrete sewers.
- Manning's n varies with flow depth in partly full circular pipes (Camp's curves).