If 20 mL of an odorous water sample is diluted with 180 mL of odour-free water to make a 200 mL mixture where the odour is just detectable, determine the threshold odour number of this water sample. Give your comments on acceptability of this sample from the consumer point of view. The odour sensitivity of an individual varies, so what may be the correct procedure and method to carry out an odour test ?
7 marks · directive: Calculate and comment
The core of a good answer
TON = (A + B)/A = (20 + 180)/20 = 10; this is well above the US EPA secondary guideline of 3 TON and does not meet the IS 10500:2012 requirement that odour be 'Agreeable', so the water is aesthetically unacceptable to consumers; the test should be run at several dilutions, cold and when heated, as IS 10500 directs.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Compute the threshold odour number, judge it against drinking water norms, and describe a standardised panel test that controls for individual differences in sensitivity.
Answer outline
Introduction
Threshold odour number is the dilution ratio at which odour is just perceptible: TON = (A + B)/A, with A = mL of sample and B = mL of odour-free water.
Calculation
- TON = (20 + 180)/20 = 200/20 = 10
Acceptability
- US EPA secondary maximum contaminant level for odour = 3 TON; secondary standards are not federally enforceable and guide aesthetic quality.
- IS 10500:2012 (Table 1, organoleptic and physical parameters) sets odour as 'Agreeable' for both the acceptable limit and the permissible limit in the absence of an alternate source.
- A TON of 10 means the odour is still just detectable after the sample has been diluted ten times, more than three times the EPA guideline value; consumers would find the water objectionable.
Correct procedure (IS 10500:2012, odour test to IS 3025 (Part 5))
- Odour is a sensory (organoleptic) parameter, so the result depends on the observer; a single sniff of the raw sample is not reliable.
- Test at several dilutions: mix measured volumes of sample with odour-free water to a fixed total volume, and find the greatest dilution at which odour is still just detectable; TON = total volume/sample volume.
- Test cold and when heated, as IS 10500 directs, because odour depends on temperature.
- Report the TON with the method (IS 3025 (Part 5)) and the test temperature stated.
Conclusion
The sample (TON 10) is aesthetically unacceptable; a dilution test done cold and hot, and repeated by more than one observer, gives a more dependable TON despite variation among individuals.
Examples and data to cite
- US EPA secondary drinking water standards list odour at 3 TON.
Facts to remember
- TON = (A + B)/A, where A = mL of sample and B = mL of odour-free dilution water.
- US EPA secondary MCL for odour = 3 TON (not federally enforceable).
- IS 10500:2012: odour 'Agreeable'; test cold and when heated, and at several dilutions; method IS 3025 (Part 5): 1983.