Explain Lacey’s silt factor. If the value of this factor is 1.0, what does it indicate ?
The longitudinal slope of a canal running in an alluvial soil is 1/5000. Design the canal section and also find discharge (Q). Take Lacey’s silt factor, f = 0.90 and the canal side slope as ½ H : 1 V.
15 marks · directive: Explain and design
The core of a good answer
Lacey's silt factor f = 1.76 √d (d in mm) measures the grade of bed material; f = 1.0 corresponds to a mean bed particle size of about 0.32 mm; for S = 1/5000 and f = 0.90, Lacey's slope equation gives Q ≈ 3.92 m³/s, V = 0.532 m/s, R = 0.787 m, A = 7.37 m², P = 9.41 m, and with ½H : 1V side slopes the section is bed width B ≈ 7.28 m and depth D ≈ 0.95 m.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain the meaning of f, then work the regime equations backwards: here slope and f are given, so Q comes from the slope equation and the section from the other regime relations.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given S = 1/5000, f = 0.90, side slope ½ H : 1 V. Lacey's regime equations: V = (Qf²/140)^(1/6); R = 5V²/(2f); P = 4.75 √Q; A = Q/V; S = f^(5/3)/(3340 Q^(1/6)).
Step 1: Silt factor
- f = 1.76 √m_r, where m_r is the mean bed particle size in mm; larger f means coarser bed material, which needs steeper slope and smaller depth.
- f = 1.0 gives m_r = (1/1.76)² = 0.323 mm, so a value of 1 indicates bed material of about 0.32 mm mean size; smaller values indicate finer material.
Step 2: Discharge from the slope equation
- Q^(1/6) = f^(5/3)/(3340 S) = 0.90^(5/3) × 5000/3340 = 1.2559
- Q = 1.2559⁶ = 3.92 m³/s
Step 3: Regime velocity and hydraulic mean depth
- V = (Qf²/140)^(1/6) = (3.924 × 0.81/140)^(1/6) = 0.532 m/s
- R = 5V²/(2f) = 2.5 × 0.532²/0.90 = 0.787 m
Step 4: Area and wetted perimeter
- A = Q/V = 3.924/0.532 = 7.37 m²
- P = 4.75 √Q = 4.75 × √3.924 = 9.41 m (check: A/P = 0.784 ≈ R)
Step 5: Section dimensions
- For side slope ½ : 1, A = BD + 0.5D², P = B + 2D√(1 + 0.25) = B + √5 D
- Substitute B = 9.41 − 2.236D: 7.37 = (9.41 − 2.236D)D + 0.5D², i.e. 1.736D² − 9.41D + 7.37 = 0
- D = 0.95 m (the other root, 4.47 m, gives negative B)
- B = 9.41 − 2.236 × 0.95 = 7.28 m
Conclusion
Design: bed width ≈ 7.3 m, full supply depth ≈ 0.95 m, side slopes ½ H : 1 V, discharge ≈ 3.92 m³/s at 0.53 m/s. Check: S = f^(5/3)/(3340 Q^(1/6)) returns 1/5000.
Examples and data to cite
- The designed section is wide and shallow: B/D = 7.28/0.95 ≈ 7.7.
Facts to remember
- Silt factor f = 1.76 √m_r (m_r in mm); f = 1 corresponds to m_r ≈ 0.323 mm.
- P = 4.75 √Q; V = (Qf²/140)^(1/6); R = (5/2)(V²/f); S = f^(5/3)/(3340 Q^(1/6)).
- Lacey (at one time Chief Engineer of the UP Irrigation Department) published his findings in 1929.
- Lacey slope relation in the form S = 0.0003 f^(5/3)/Q^(1/6) is the same as S = f^(5/3)/(3340 Q^(1/6)).