Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Distinguish between Amalgamation in the nature of merger and Amalgamation in the nature of purchase.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Distinguish
The core of a good answer
Under AS 14, an amalgamation in the nature of merger is a genuine pooling of two businesses that meets all five prescribed conditions and is accounted for by the pooling of interests method at book values with reserves preserved; any amalgamation that fails even one condition is in the nature of purchase and is accounted for by the purchase method, with goodwill or capital reserve arising.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks for a point-by-point contrast. The answer should first state the AS 14 conditions that make an amalgamation a merger, then compare the two types on accounting method, valuation, reserves and the treatment of the difference between consideration and net assets.
Answer outline
Introduction
AS 14, Accounting for Amalgamations, issued by ICAI, classifies every amalgamation into one of two types.
Conditions for merger (all must be met)
- All assets and liabilities of the transferor company become those of the transferee company.
- Shareholders holding not less than 90% of the face value of the transferor's equity shares become equity shareholders of the transferee.
- Consideration to those equity holders is discharged wholly by equity shares of the transferee, except cash for fractional shares.
- The transferor's business is intended to be carried on by the transferee.
- No adjustment is made to the book values of assets and liabilities, except to ensure uniform accounting policies.
Points of difference
- Nature: merger is a pooling of shareholders' interests and businesses; purchase is one company acquiring another.
- Method: pooling of interests method for merger; purchase method for purchase.
- Valuation: book values in merger; in purchase, assets and liabilities may be recorded at book value or at fair values.
- Reserves: in merger all reserves of the transferor keep their identity in the transferee's books; in purchase only statutory reserves are carried forward, through an Amalgamation Adjustment Reserve.
- Difference between consideration and share capital: adjusted against reserves in merger; in purchase the excess of consideration over net assets is goodwill and the shortfall is capital reserve.
- Goodwill arising in purchase is amortised over a period not exceeding five years unless a somewhat longer period can be justified.
Conclusion
The test is substance: if shareholders of both companies continue as partners in the combined business without revaluation, AS 14 treats it as a merger; otherwise it is a purchase.
Examples and data to cite
- If a transferee pays part of the consideration to the transferor's equity holders in cash or debentures, the condition of payment wholly in equity shares fails and the amalgamation becomes one in the nature of purchase.
- If only 85% of the transferor's equity holders join the transferee, the 90% condition fails, so it is a purchase.
Facts to remember
- AS 14 recognises two methods: pooling of interests method (merger) and purchase method (purchase).
- Consideration under AS 14 (paragraph 3) is the aggregate of the shares and other securities issued and the payment made in the form of cash or other assets by the transferee to the shareholders of the transferor; liabilities taken over are therefore not part of it.
- Statutory reserves in a purchase are preserved by debiting Amalgamation Adjustment Reserve and crediting the statutory reserve.