Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
What do you understand by ‘marginal costing’ ? How is marginal costing useful for solving various managerial problems ?
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Marginal costing charges only variable costs to products and treats fixed costs as period costs written off against total contribution; by isolating contribution it gives management a direct basis for decisions on pricing, product mix, key factors, make or buy, special orders and closure of segments.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must define marginal costing and its key features, then show through specific decision areas how the contribution approach solves managerial problems. A short numerical illustration strengthens the answer within 150 words.
Answer outline
Introduction
Marginal costing (variable or direct costing) is a technique in which only variable costs are charged to cost units, while fixed costs of the period are written off in full against aggregate contribution.
Features
- Costs are split into fixed and variable; semi-variable costs are separated.
- Stocks of work in progress and finished goods are valued at marginal (variable) cost.
- Contribution = Sales − Variable cost; Profit = Contribution − Fixed cost.
- Cost-volume-profit analysis (P/V ratio, break-even point, margin of safety) is integral to it.
Uses in managerial problems
- Pricing: in a slump or for an export or special order, any price above marginal cost adds to contribution if spare capacity exists and the regular market is not affected.
- Make or buy: compare the purchase price with the marginal cost of making, plus any opportunity cost of capacity.
- Key or limiting factor: rank products by contribution per unit of the scarce factor (labour hour, machine hour, material).
- Product mix and sales mix: choose the combination giving maximum total contribution.
- Shut down or continue: a segment with positive contribution helps cover fixed costs and should not be closed merely because it shows a loss after allocated fixed costs.
- Profit planning: sales needed for a target profit = (Fixed cost + Target profit) ÷ P/V ratio.
- Evaluation of alternatives such as mechanisation, which changes the mix of fixed and variable cost.
Illustration
- A component can be bought for ₹20; making it needs variable cost of ₹18 and existing fixed cost would be incurred anyway. With idle capacity, making saves ₹2 per unit.
Conclusion
Marginal costing is a decision tool rather than a complete costing system; its usefulness depends on a correct split of costs and it ignores long-run recovery of fixed costs.
Examples and data to cite
- Special order example: if variable cost is ₹60 per unit and spare capacity exists, an order at ₹70 adds ₹10 per unit to profit even though the full cost may be ₹80.
- Make or buy example above: variable cost of making ₹18 versus purchase price ₹20.
Facts to remember
- Contribution = Sales − Variable cost = Fixed cost + Profit.
- Under marginal costing, closing stock excludes fixed manufacturing overhead, so profit differs from absorption costing profit when production and sales differ.
- With a limiting factor, products are ranked by contribution per unit of the limiting factor.
- Limitations: difficulty of separating semi-variable costs, assumption of linear costs, and undervaluation of stock for external reporting.