Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Explain the major points to be considered by an auditor while auditing the accounts of a charitable trust.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
An auditor of a charitable trust must verify that receipts are fully recorded, that income has been applied to the trust's objects as required by the trust deed and by sections 11 to 13 of the Income-tax Act, that registration and statutory conditions are met, and that no benefit has passed to interested persons, before reporting in the prescribed form under section 12A(1)(b) and under any applicable State trust law.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should list the special audit points that arise from the trust's charitable character and its tax exemption, not routine audit procedures. A good answer groups points under constitution, income, application, assets and investments, and statutory compliance.
Answer outline
Introduction
A charitable trust holds property for public charitable purposes; its accounts are audited under the trust deed, State public trust laws where applicable, and section 12A(1)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which makes audit of the accounts by an accountant a condition for the exemption.
Constitution and registration
- Study the trust deed: objects, powers of trustees, investment and borrowing powers, accounting year.
- Check registration of the trust under the Income-tax Act and approval under section 80G (approvals granted for not more than five years at a time under the 2020 amendment), and registration under the State public trusts Act where applicable.
- Read minutes of trustees' meetings for authorisation of major expenditure.
Income and receipts
- Vouch donations with receipt counterfoils; examine control over receipt books and cash collections, including donation boxes opened in the presence of trustees.
- Distinguish corpus donations (specific direction) from general donations.
- Verify rent, interest and dividend income from the investment and property registers.
Application of income
- Confirm that at least 85% of income has been applied to charitable purposes in India, and that any further accumulation is for a specified purpose, backed by a statement in the prescribed form furnished within the time allowed, for a period not exceeding five years.
- Vouch grants, scholarships and charitable payments with approvals and beneficiary acknowledgements.
- Check that no income or property has been used for the benefit of the author, trustees or their relatives (section 13).
Assets, investments and other checks
- Verify title deeds and physical existence of property; ensure funds are invested only in modes allowed by section 11(5).
- Check depreciation and fixed asset records.
- Examine expenses of administration for reasonableness and see that budgets, where required, have been followed.
Reporting
- Report in the form prescribed under the Income-tax Rules and in the format required by the State trust law.
- Comment on irregularities, misapplication of funds and non-compliance.
Conclusion
The audit of a charitable trust is essentially a check on stewardship: every rupee received is accounted for and spent on the declared objects within the law.
Examples and data to cite
- Section 11(5) lists the only forms and modes in which a trust may invest or deposit the money it accumulates; an investment outside these modes is a point for the auditor to report.
- Under the Finance Act, 2020 amendments, approval under section 80G is granted for not more than five years at a time and donees must furnish a statement of donations received, so the auditor checks the approval's validity and the donation records.
Facts to remember
- Section 11(1)(a): income applied to charitable purposes in India is exempt, and accumulation of income not in excess of 15% is also exempt.
- Section 11(2): further accumulation for a specified purpose is allowed for a period that shall in no case exceed five years, on furnishing a statement in the prescribed form and manner.
- Section 13(1)(c): exemption is lost to the extent income or property is used for the benefit of specified interested persons.
- Section 12A(1)(b): the accounts of the trust must be audited by an accountant and the audit report furnished in the prescribed form.