Mr. A of Agra submits the following particulars of his let out residential house :
(A) Rent received for house as well as for various amenities provided to the tenant.
Amount (₹)
(i) For House 16,000 per month
(ii) For lift maintenance 1,600 per month
(iii) For security charges 1,400 per month
(iv) For electricity and water 1,600 per month
(B) Municipal valuation 1,70,000 per annum
(C) Fair Rental value 1,52,000 per annum
(D) Standard Rent 1,40,000 per annum
(E) Municipal Taxes 10% of Municipal valuation (50% to be paid by tenant)
(F) Repair expenses met by tenant 10,000
(G) Insurance premium 2,000
(H) Interest on loan taken in 2014 for Renovation of the house 50,000 per annum
(I) Unrealized rent recovered (Actual ₹48,000 but deduction allowed ₹36,000 only) 24,000
Compute Mr. A's income from house property and any other income for the Assessment year 2025-26, assuming that Mr. A spent ₹22,000 on providing facilities to the tenant.
20 marks · directive: Compute
The core of a good answer
Income from house property is ₹95,250 (₹78,450 from the let-out house plus ₹16,800 from unrealised rent recovered under section 25A), and income from other sources from the separately charged amenities is ₹33,200.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The method is the computation of income from house property under sections 22 to 25A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for previous year 2024-25, with the separately charged amenities taxed under Income from other sources. The key judgments are separating composite rent, finding gross annual value, deducting only the owner's share of municipal tax, and taxing the unrealised rent recovered under section 25A.
Answer outline
Introduction
Assessment year 2025-26 (previous year 2024-25). The rent received for the house and the charges for amenities are separate, so only the house rent is considered under the head house property; the amenity charges go to Income from other sources with the cost of providing them deductible.
Step 1: Split the composite rent
- Rent for house = 16,000 × 12 = ₹1,92,000.
- Amenity charges = (1,600 + 1,400 + 1,600) × 12 = 4,600 × 12 = ₹55,200 (taxed under Income from other sources).
Step 2: Expected rent (section 23(1)(a))
- Higher of municipal valuation ₹1,70,000 and fair rent ₹1,52,000 = ₹1,70,000.
- Limited to standard rent ₹1,40,000, so expected rent = ₹1,40,000.
Step 3: Gross annual value (section 23(1)(b))
- Actual rent received ₹1,92,000 is higher than expected rent ₹1,40,000.
- Gross annual value = ₹1,92,000.
Step 4: Municipal taxes
- Municipal tax = 10% × 1,70,000 = ₹17,000.
- Borne by owner = 50% × 17,000 = ₹8,500 (deductible, assuming paid during the year); the tenant's share is not deductible.
- Net annual value = 1,92,000 − 8,500 = ₹1,83,500.
Step 5: Deductions under section 24
- Standard deduction 30% × 1,83,500 = ₹55,050 (covers repairs and insurance, so the insurance premium ₹2,000 and the tenant's repairs ₹10,000 are not separately deductible).
- Interest on loan for renovation under section 24(b) = ₹50,000 (no ceiling for a let-out house).
- Income from the let-out house = 1,83,500 − 55,050 − 50,000 = ₹78,450.
Step 6: Unrealised rent recovered (section 25A)
- Amount recovered = ₹24,000; deduction 30% = ₹7,200.
- Taxable = 24,000 − 7,200 = ₹16,800.
- Total income from house property = 78,450 + 16,800 = ₹95,250.
Step 7: Income from other sources
- Amenity charges ₹55,200 less expenses on providing facilities ₹22,000 = ₹33,200.
Conclusion
Income from house property ₹95,250; income from other sources ₹33,200. Check: 1,92,000 − 8,500 − 55,050 − 50,000 + 16,800 = 95,250.
Examples and data to cite
- Section 25A, as substituted by the Finance Act, 2016 with effect from 1 April 2017, taxes the unrealised rent realised subsequently from a tenant as income from house property of the year of receipt, and allows a deduction of 30% of that amount; so the full ₹24,000 recovered is taxed after the 30% deduction.
Facts to remember
- Gross annual value = higher of expected rent and actual rent received or receivable (section 23(1)).
- Expected rent = higher of municipal value and fair rent, but not exceeding standard rent under the rent control law.
- Municipal taxes are deductible only if borne by the owner and actually paid in the year (proviso to section 23(1)).
- Section 24(a): 30% of the annual value; section 24(b): interest payable on capital borrowed where the property has been acquired, constructed, repaired, renewed or reconstructed with borrowed capital.
- The amenity charges are treated here as income from other sources, with the ₹22,000 spent on the facilities deducted from them, because they are charged separately from the rent for the house.