Answer each of the following questions in about 150 words :
Explain the CAPM approach for computing the cost of equity. Discuss the merits and demerits of the approach.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Under the Capital Asset Pricing Model the cost of equity is the risk-free rate plus beta times the market risk premium, Ke = Rf + β(Rm − Rf); it prices only systematic risk and is simple to apply, but it rests on restrictive assumptions and on inputs (beta, market premium) that are hard to estimate reliably.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has two parts: show how CAPM yields the shareholders' required return (formula, meaning of each term, a short illustration), and then weigh its strengths against its weaknesses. In about 150 words the answer must be compact: formula, two or three lines on logic, then balanced merits and demerits.
Answer outline
Introduction
The cost of equity is the minimum return shareholders require; CAPM, developed independently by Jack Treynor (1961, 1962), William Sharpe (1964), John Lintner (1965) and Jan Mossin (1966) on Markowitz's portfolio theory, estimates it from the risk an investor cannot diversify away.
CAPM approach
- Ke = Rf + β(Rm − Rf), where Rf is the risk-free rate (yield on government securities), Rm the expected market return and β the sensitivity of the share's return to market return.
- β = Cov(Ri, Rm) / Var(Rm); β > 1 means the share is more sensitive to market movements than the market itself, β < 1 less sensitive.
- (Rm − Rf) is the market risk premium; β(Rm − Rf) is the share's risk premium.
- Illustration: Rf = 7%, Rm = 12%, β = 1.2 gives Ke = 7% + 1.2 × 5% = 13%.
- Graphically the relation is the Security Market Line.
Merits
- Considers only systematic (market) risk, which is the risk a diversified investor is rewarded for.
- Usable for firms that pay no dividend or have no stable growth, where the dividend growth model fails.
- Simple, linear, and based on observable market data; gives a risk-adjusted discount rate for project appraisal.
Demerits
- Assumptions are unrealistic: perfect markets, no taxes or transaction costs, homogeneous expectations, unlimited borrowing and lending at Rf.
- Beta is estimated from past data and is unstable over time; results change with the period and index chosen.
- The true market portfolio is unobservable (Roll's critique, 1977), and the choice of Rf and of the market premium is subjective.
- Empirical tests show other factors (size, value) explain returns, and Fama and French (2004) concluded that this empirical failure makes most applications of the model invalid.
Conclusion
CAPM gives a theoretically sound, market-based cost of equity, but its result should be cross-checked with the dividend growth or bond-yield-plus-premium approach.
Examples and data to cite
- Treynor (1961, 1962), Sharpe (1964), Lintner (1965) and Mossin (1966) developed CAPM independently; Sharpe shared the 1990 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences with Markowitz and Miller.
- Roll's critique (1977): the market portfolio cannot be observed, so stock index proxies may mislead.
- Fama and French (2004) argued that the failure of CAPM in empirical tests implies that most applications of the model are invalid.
Facts to remember
- Ke = Rf + β(Rm − Rf).
- β = Cov(Ri, Rm)/Var(Rm); market β = 1.
- Only systematic risk is priced; unsystematic risk is diversifiable.
- The Security Market Line plots required return against β.