Answer each of the following questions in about 150 words :
Discuss Gordon's model of dividend decision.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Gordon's model treats dividend policy as relevant: share price P = E(1 − b)/(k − br), so retention raises value when r > k, lowers it when r < k and is neutral when r = k; and investors are seen to prefer certain dividends to uncertain future capital gains (the bird-in-hand argument).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must state the model, its formula and assumptions, show how the optimal payout depends on the relation between the firm's return r and cost of equity k, add the bird-in-hand reasoning and close with limitations. A short numerical illustration strengthens a 150-word answer.
Answer outline
Introduction
Myron J. Gordon developed a dividend capitalisation model (with Eli Shapiro, 1956, and in later work such as "Dividends, Earnings and Stock Prices", 1959) holding that the market price of a share equals the present value of an infinite stream of dividends, so dividend policy affects value.
Assumptions
- All-equity firm; investment financed only from retained earnings.
- Internal rate of return (r) and cost of equity (k) are constant; k > br = g.
- Constant retention ratio (b) and hence constant growth g = br; perpetual life; no taxes.
Model
- P = E(1 − b) / (k − br) = D₁ / (k − g).
- Illustration: E = ₹10, k = 12%. If r = 15%: b = 0 gives P = 10/0.12 = ₹83.33; b = 0.4 gives g = 6%, D = ₹6, P = 6/0.06 = ₹100.
- If r = 12%: price is ₹83.33 whatever b is. If r = 10%: b = 0.4 gives g = 4%, P = 6/0.08 = ₹75, below ₹83.33.
Implications for payout
- Growth firm (r > k): low payout or full retention maximises price.
- Normal firm (r = k): payout is irrelevant in the basic model.
- Declining firm (r < k): 100% payout maximises price.
- Bird-in-hand: investors are seen to prefer dividends because they are certain, compared with uncertain income from future capital gains.
Limitations
- Ignores external financing and debt.
- Constant r and k are unrealistic; k rises with risk.
- Price explodes as g approaches k; the model fails when g ≥ k.
- Ignores taxes and flotation costs.
Conclusion
Gordon's model, like Walter's, makes the dividend decision depend on the firm's investment opportunities relative to the cost of capital, and adds the bird-in-hand argument that certain dividends are preferred to uncertain capital gains.
Examples and data to cite
- Gordon and Shapiro (1956) published the constant growth model; it builds on John Burr Williams, The Theory of Investment Value (1938).
- Numerical check: E = ₹10, k = 12%, r = 15%, b = 0.4 gives P = ₹100 against ₹83.33 at full payout.
Facts to remember
- P = E(1 − b)/(k − br).
- g = b × r (retention ratio × return on retained earnings, the sustainable growth rate).
- k = D₁/P + g (dividend yield plus growth).
- Model valid only if k > g.