Answer each of the following questions in about 150 words :
Discuss the role of credit rating agencies in India.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Credit rating agencies in India give independent opinions on the likelihood of timely repayment of debt, which lowers information costs for investors, prices risk for borrowers, and feeds into regulation such as Basel capital standards; but the issuer-pays model and the 2018 IL&FS default, which rating agencies did not foresee, show their limitations and the need for SEBI oversight.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should explain what a credit rating is, list the Indian agencies and their regulator, and then discuss their role for investors, issuers, regulators and the market, closing with problems and reforms.
Answer outline
Introduction
A credit rating is an opinion, expressed in symbols such as AAA or D, on the relative ability and willingness of an issuer to meet debt obligations in time; in India agencies are registered and regulated by SEBI under the SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999.
Indian agencies
- CRISIL, promoted by ICICI and UTI, was India's first rating agency (1987 to 1988); majority-owned by S&P Global since 2005.
- ICRA (1991), majority-owned by Moody's.
- CareEdge Ratings, Acuité Ratings & Research and others.
Role for investors
- Simple, comparable measure of default risk; reduces cost of information and analysis for small investors.
- Helps institutional investors meet investment mandates that restrict them to rated or investment-grade paper.
Role for issuers and markets
- Good rating lowers the coupon and widens the investor base; rating is a marketing tool.
- Deepens the corporate bond and commercial paper market; ratings for bank loans, structured finance, SME and municipal bonds.
- Continuous surveillance and rating changes act as early warning signals.
Role in regulation
- SEBI registers and regulates rating agencies under the SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999.
- The Basel III accord relies on credit ratings to calculate minimum capital standards and liquidity ratios for banks.
Problems
- Issuer-pays model creates conflict of interest and rating shopping.
- Failure to warn: IL&FS defaulted in 2018, and in April 2020 the Corporate Affairs Secretary remarked that nobody, including credit rating agencies, foresaw the problem.
- Overreliance on ratings by regulators and investors.
Conclusion
Rating agencies are key information intermediaries in India's debt market; their usefulness depends on independence, transparent methodology and timely action, which SEBI oversees as regulator.
Examples and data to cite
- CRISIL was launched jointly by ICICI and UTI as India's first credit rating agency.
- ICRA was established in 1991 as Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency of India.
- IL&FS defaulted on its loans in 2018; in April 2020 the Corporate Affairs Secretary faulted gatekeepers, including credit rating agencies, for not foreseeing the problem.
- Globally, ratings of mortgage-backed securities before the 2008 crisis were heavily criticised: 73% of mortgage-backed securities Moody's rated AAA in 2006 were downgraded to junk two years later.
Facts to remember
- SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999 govern CRAs.
- On S&P and Fitch scales AAA, AA, A and BBB (with plus and minus modifiers) are investment grade.
- A rating is an opinion, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold.