The following is the data regarding two companies X and Y belonging to the same equivalent risk class :
Company X | Company Y
Number of Equity Shares: 2,00,000 | 3,00,000
10% Debentures: 1,00,000 | –
Market price per share: ₹1.30 | ₹1.00
Profit before interest: ₹40,000 | ₹40,000
All profits after paying interest on debentures are distributed as dividends. Explain how under Modigliani and Miller approach, an investor holding 10% of shares in Company X will be better off in switching his holdings to Company Y.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Levered X is overvalued (₹3,60,000 against ₹3,00,000 for Y); an investor with 10% of X sells shares for ₹26,000, borrows ₹10,000 at 10% (homemade leverage equal to his share of X's debt), buys 36,000 Y shares (12% of Y) and earns ₹4,800 − ₹1,000 = ₹3,800 instead of ₹3,000, a gain of ₹800 with the same financial risk.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
This is a Modigliani and Miller (1958) Proposition I arbitrage problem. The method is: value both firms, identify the overvalued levered firm, compute the investor's present income, then replicate X's leverage personally by borrowing, buy into Y, and compare income (or the outlay needed for the same income).
Answer outline
Introduction
Data: EBIT ₹40,000 each; X has ₹1,00,000 of 10% debentures and 2,00,000 shares at ₹1.30; Y is unlevered with 3,00,000 shares at ₹1.00. Personal borrowing is assumed possible at 10%, the same rate as the company's debt.
Step 1: Value the firms
- X: interest = 10% × 1,00,000 = ₹10,000; dividends = 40,000 − 10,000 = ₹30,000.
- X: market value of equity = 2,00,000 × 1.30 = ₹2,60,000; value of firm = 2,60,000 + 1,00,000 = ₹3,60,000.
- Y: value of equity = value of firm = 3,00,000 × 1.00 = ₹3,00,000.
- Overall cost of capital: X = 40,000/3,60,000 = 11.11%; Y = 40,000/3,00,000 = 13.33%. Cost of equity of X = 30,000/2,60,000 = 11.54%.
- Same EBIT and risk class but different values, so MM says X is overvalued and arbitrage is possible.
Step 2: Present position of the investor
- Holds 10% of X = 20,000 shares worth 20,000 × 1.30 = ₹26,000.
- Income = 10% × 30,000 = ₹3,000.
Step 3: Arbitrage with homemade leverage
- Sell X shares: ₹26,000.
- Borrow personally 10% of X's debt = ₹10,000 at 10% (keeps his financial risk the same as before).
- Total funds = ₹36,000; buy 36,000 shares of Y at ₹1 = 36,000/3,00,000 = 12% of Y.
Step 4: New income
- Dividend from Y = 12% × 40,000 = ₹4,800.
- Less interest on personal loan = 10% × 10,000 = ₹1,000.
- Net income = ₹3,800 against ₹3,000 earlier: better off by ₹800.
Step 5: Alternative view (same income, less outlay)
- Y pays 40,000/3,00,000 = ₹0.1333 per share.
- To get ₹3,000 net he needs ₹4,000 gross, i.e. 30,000 Y shares costing ₹30,000.
- Out of ₹36,000 he saves ₹6,000 while earning the same ₹3,000.
Conclusion
Switching raises the investor's income from ₹3,000 to ₹3,800 at the same risk (check: 0.12 × 40,000 − 1,000 = 3,800). Such selling of X and buying of Y will continue until the market values of the two firms are equal, which is MM's capital structure irrelevance result.
Examples and data to cite
- Modigliani and Miller, 'The Cost of Capital, Corporation Finance and the Theory of Investment', American Economic Review, 1958.
Facts to remember
- MM Proposition I (no taxes): V_L = V_U; value depends on EBIT and risk class, not on financing mix.
- Arbitrage requires personal borrowing at the same rate as corporate borrowing, no transaction costs and perfect markets.
- Value of firm = market value of equity + market value of debt.
- Overall cost of capital ko = EBIT / V.