The earning per share of a company is ₹9 and the rate of capitalisation applicable is 12 percent. The company has before it, an option of adopting (i) 50, (ii) 60 and (iii) 100 percent dividend payout ratio.
Compute the market price of the company’s quoted shares as per Walter’s Model if it can earn a return of (A) 15, (B) 12 and (C) 5 percent of its retained earnings.
15 marks · directive: Compute
The core of a good answer
By Walter's formula P = [D + (r/k)(E − D)]/k with E = ₹9 and k = 12%: at r = 15% the prices are ₹84.375, ₹82.50 and ₹75 for 50%, 60% and 100% payout; at r = 12% the price is ₹75 for every payout; at r = 5% the prices are ₹53.125, ₹57.50 and ₹75.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Apply Walter's model to nine combinations (three payout ratios, three returns on retained earnings) and interpret: price falls with payout when r > k, is unaffected when r = k, and rises with payout when r < k.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given E = ₹9, k = 0.12; payout 50% (D = ₹4.50, retained ₹4.50), 60% (D = ₹5.40, retained ₹3.60), 100% (D = ₹9, retained 0); r = 0.15, 0.12, 0.05.
Step 1: Formula
- P = [D + (r/k)(E − D)] / k.
Step 2: (A) r = 15%, r/k = 1.25
- 50%: P = [4.50 + 1.25 × 4.50]/0.12 = (4.50 + 5.625)/0.12 = 10.125/0.12 = ₹84.375
- 60%: P = [5.40 + 1.25 × 3.60]/0.12 = (5.40 + 4.50)/0.12 = 9.90/0.12 = ₹82.50
- 100%: P = 9/0.12 = ₹75
Step 3: (B) r = 12%, r/k = 1
- 50%: (4.50 + 4.50)/0.12 = ₹75
- 60%: (5.40 + 3.60)/0.12 = ₹75
- 100%: 9/0.12 = ₹75
Step 4: (C) r = 5%, r/k = 0.4167
- 50%: [4.50 + (5/12) × 4.50]/0.12 = (4.50 + 1.875)/0.12 = 6.375/0.12 = ₹53.125
- 60%: [5.40 + (5/12) × 3.60]/0.12 = (5.40 + 1.50)/0.12 = 6.90/0.12 = ₹57.50
- 100%: 9/0.12 = ₹75
Step 5: Summary table (₹)
- Payout 50%: A 84.375; B 75; C 53.125
- Payout 60%: A 82.50; B 75; C 57.50
- Payout 100%: A 75; B 75; C 75
Conclusion
Growth firm (r = 15% > k): the lowest payout (50%) gives the highest price, and nil payout would be optimal. Normal firm (r = k): payout is irrelevant, price ₹75. Declining firm (r = 5% < k): 100% payout maximises price at ₹75. Check: at 100% payout P = E/k = 9/0.12 = ₹75 in all cases.
Examples and data to cite
- All nine prices recomputed exactly in Python.
Facts to remember
- Walter's model: P = [D + (r/k)(E − D)]/k.
- Assumptions: all-equity firm financed by retained earnings only, constant r and k, all earnings either distributed or reinvested, infinite life.
- Optimal payout: 0% if r > k, 100% if r < k, irrelevant if r = k.