Explain the various types of organisational culture.
10 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Organisational culture can be classified in several ways: Deal and Kennedy's four cultures based on risk and speed of feedback; Cameron and Quinn's Competing Values Framework, which builds four culture types from two dimensions; and simpler contrasts such as strong versus weak culture and an organisation's culture versus its subcultures.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the main typologies of organisational culture with a short description of each type. It helps to define culture first, present two or three recognised typologies with their basis of classification, and note that real organisations show mixtures.
Answer outline
Introduction
Edgar Schein defines culture as the pattern of basic assumptions that a group has invented, discovered or developed in solving its problems of external adaptation and internal integration; Deal and Kennedy (1982) put it simply as the way things get done around here.
Cameron and Quinn, Competing Values Framework (1999)
- Based on two dimensions: internal versus external focus, and stability (structure, planning, reliability) versus flexibility (quick adaptation, emphasis on people).
- Placing the two dimensions in a two by two matrix gives four culture types, one of which is called clan culture.
- The Organizational Culture Assessment Instrument (OCAI), developed by Kim Cameron and Robert Quinn at the University of Michigan, is based on this framework and asks respondents to distribute 100 points among the four competing values.
Deal and Kennedy (Corporate Cultures, 1982)
- Based on two dimensions: degree of (financial) risk and speed of feedback, that is, how quickly an action proves beneficial or harmful.
- Tough guy macho (high risk, fast feedback), work hard play hard (low risk, fast feedback), bet your company (high risk, slow feedback) and process (low risk, slow feedback).
Other classifications
- Strong versus weak culture: a strong culture uses reinforcing tools such as ceremonies and policies to instil its values, and researchers generally find organisations with strong cultures more successful; in a weak culture there is little conviction, so control relies on procedures and bureaucracy.
- Subcultures: groups within the organisation, such as individual management teams, may act according to their own subcultures.
- Adaptive culture (Kotter and Heskett): managers pay close attention to their constituencies, initiate change and take risks, and such organisations are reported to perform better.
Conclusion
No type is best in all settings; the right culture fits the organisation's strategy and environment, and real organisations combine elements of several types.
Examples and data to cite
- A process culture (low risk, slow feedback) in Deal and Kennedy's scheme is the bureaucratic culture typical of administrative organisations.
- Deal and Kennedy's bet-your-company culture (high risk, slow feedback) fits organisations whose major decisions take years to prove right or wrong.
Facts to remember
- Schein's three levels: artefacts and behaviours, espoused values, shared basic assumptions.
- Cameron and Quinn's Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture: Based on the Competing Values Framework appeared in 1999.
- Deal and Kennedy's Corporate Cultures appeared in 1982.