Define organisational design. Explain in detail the salient features of organisational design that managers must consider.
20 marks · directive: Define and explain
The core of a good answer
Organisational design is the process by which managers choose and fit together the elements of structure (specialisation, departmentalisation, chain of command, span of control, centralisation and formalisation) with strategy, environment, technology, size and people, so that work is divided and coordinated effectively.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has two parts: a definition and a detailed account of the design features managers must decide on. A full answer explains the structural variables one by one, then the contingency factors that decide which design fits, and ends with the common design options and alignment models.
Answer outline
Introduction
Organisational design is the deliberate process of creating or changing an organisation's structure and its supporting systems; the outcome is the organisational structure, the formal arrangement of tasks, authority and communication.
Structural elements managers must decide
- Work specialisation: how far tasks are divided into separate jobs; gains in efficiency against boredom and fatigue.
- Departmentalisation: grouping by function, product, geography, process or customer.
- Chain of command and unity of command: who reports to whom; Fayol's unity of command says every employee should receive orders from only one superior.
- Span of control: number of subordinates per manager; wide spans give flat structures, narrow spans give tall ones.
- Centralisation versus decentralisation: where decisions are made.
- Formalisation: degree to which jobs are standardised by rules and procedures.
- Coordination and integration devices: liaison roles, committees, task forces, integrating managers.
Contingency factors that shape design
- Strategy: Alfred Chandler (Strategy and Structure, 1962) found that managerial organisation developed in response to the corporation's business strategy.
- Environment: Burns and Stalker (The Management of Innovation, 1961): firms in stable environments benefit from mechanistic structures, while firms in changing environments may need organic structures with decentralised decisions.
- Technology: Joan Woodward (Industrial Organization, 1965) classified firms as unit (small scale), mass (large scale) and continuous process, and found successful firms in each category shared a particular structure.
- Size: the Aston researchers found larger organisations generally more specialised, standardised and formalised, with less centralised decision making.
- Differentiation and integration: Lawrence and Lorsch (Organization and Environment, 1967): work is divided into tasks (differentiation) and their results are unified into a meaningful whole (integration).
Design options
- Simple, functional, divisional, matrix, team, network, virtual and boundaryless designs.
- Mintzberg's configurations (The Structuring of Organizations, 1979): simple structure, machine bureaucracy, professional bureaucracy, diversified (divisionalised) form, adhocracy and the missionary organisation.
Alignment and human factors
- Jay Galbraith's Star Model aligns structure, process, rewards, metrics and talent with the strategy of the business.
- Job design (Hackman and Oldham's job characteristics: skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, feedback), motivation and culture must fit the structure.
- Design must allow for change: periodic review, flexibility and learning.
Conclusion
Good organisational design is a fit, not a formula: managers must match structural choices to strategy and context, and keep revising them as the context changes.
Examples and data to cite
- Chandler records that inventory crises in 1920 to 1921 at DuPont and General Motors prompted structural changes later seen as America's first multidivisional corporations.
- Starbucks is cited as a matrix structure: functional and product based divisions, with employees reporting to two heads.
- Valve, GitHub and 37signals are examples of firms that tried to stay flat as they grew, without middle managers; GitHub later introduced middle managers.
- H&M outsources its clothing to a network of 700 suppliers.
Facts to remember
- Burns and Stalker (1961): mechanistic versus organic.
- Chandler (1962): managerial organisation develops in response to strategy.
- Lawrence and Lorsch's Organization and Environment (1967) added contingency theory to the vocabulary of organisational behaviour.
- Mintzberg's The Structuring of Organizations was published in 1979.