Discuss the methods of managing and changing organisational culture.
10 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Culture is managed and changed mainly through leadership behaviour and the systems that reinforce it: leaders signal what matters through vision, visible commitment, role modelling, rewards, selection and socialisation, and planned change models such as Kotter's give the process a sequence.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks how organisations maintain and alter culture. The answer should cover the mechanisms that sustain an existing culture, the methods used to change it, and the difficulties involved.
Answer outline
Introduction
Culture, in Schein's model, has three levels (artefacts, espoused values, basic assumptions); managing it means shaping all three, and change is hardest at the level of assumptions.
Managing (sustaining) culture
- Selection of people who fit core values.
- Socialisation: induction, mentoring, stories, rituals, symbols.
- Top management actions and role modelling.
- Reinforcing tools such as ceremonies and policies, which a strong culture uses to instil and spread its values.
Methods of changing culture
- Diagnose the current culture through surveys, interviews and focus groups (for example the Competing Values Framework).
- Set a clear vision of the desired culture and win visible commitment from top management.
- Change structure, systems, rewards and appraisal to support new behaviour.
- Change people: new leaders, new hires, training and, where needed, exit of those who do not fit.
- Use symbols, stories and quick wins; communicate continually.
Change models
- Unfreeze, change, refreeze: the model usually attributed to Kurt Lewin (died 1947), though some scholars argue it took form after his death.
- Kotter (1995): eight stages of change, beginning with creating a sense of urgency; Cummings and Worley align their six culture change guidelines with these stages.
- Kotter and Heskett's adaptive culture, in which managers attend to constituencies, initiate change and take risks, is a common target of change.
Difficulties
- Culture is deep and slow to change; resistance from those who benefit from the old ways.
- Mergers bring clashes of culture.
Conclusion
Changing culture is a long term leadership task: it succeeds when words, systems and leader behaviour all point the same way.
Examples and data to cite
- Satya Nadella, who became Microsoft's CEO in 2014, led a shift towards a growth mindset and continual learning; his 2017 book Hit Refresh reflects on his years at the company.
- Cummings and Worley's guidelines include strategic vision, top management commitment, modelling, supporting organisational changes, selecting and socialising newcomers, and ethical sensitivity.
Facts to remember
- Schein's model has three levels of culture: artefacts and behaviours, espoused values, shared basic assumptions.
- The three step unfreeze, change, refreeze model is attributed to Lewin, but there is evidence it took form after his death in 1947.
- Kotter's eight step model was published in 1995 and the book Leading Change in 1996.