Evaluate critically the impact of Total Quality Management (TQM) on employees’ behaviour and organisational effectiveness.
10 marks · directive: Evaluate critically
The core of a good answer
TQM can make employees more involved, cooperative and customer minded and can raise quality, productivity and customer satisfaction, but these gains depend on genuine top management commitment; where TQM is imposed as a slogan or used to intensify work, it produces cynicism, stress and failed programmes.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks for a balanced judgement of TQM's effects on two levels: employee behaviour and overall organisational effectiveness. The answer should explain TQM's principles briefly, then the positive and negative effects at each level, with evidence and examples.
Answer outline
Introduction
Total Quality Management is an organisation wide effort to install and make permanent a climate in which employees continuously improve their ability to serve customers; it draws on the teachings of Deming, Juran, Feigenbaum, Crosby and Ishikawa.
Principles
- Customer focus, top management responsibility, continuous improvement (kaizen), process approach, decisions based on data, employee involvement and teamwork.
- Tools: PDCA cycle, seven basic quality tools, quality circles, cross functional teams.
Impact on employee behaviour
- Positive: greater participation, empowerment and ownership; teamwork across functions; learning of problem solving skills; pride in work.
- Negative: work intensification and peer pressure; more monitoring; stress from targets; cynicism if suggestions are ignored.
Impact on organisational effectiveness
- Lower defects and cost of poor quality, higher productivity and customer satisfaction, stronger reputation.
- Award frameworks such as the Deming Prize and the Baldrige award (whose judging categories include the workforce) recognise organisation wide quality.
- Limits: TQM is vaguely defined, with no specification or standard and no certification to prove it; in the 1990s it was largely supplanted by ISO 9000, and Six Sigma and lean drew attention away from it.
Conclusion
TQM improves both employee behaviour and effectiveness when it is a genuine cultural change led from the top with real employee voice; as a short term technique it tends to fail.
Examples and data to cite
- The brakes division of Sundaram-Clayton won the Deming Prize in 1998.
- The Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award was created in August 1987 by Public Law 100-107.
- The US Navy branded its quality programme 'Total Quality Management' in 1985.
Facts to remember
- The Deming Prize was established in 1951 and is sponsored by JUSE.
- Deming's 14 points include 'Drive out fear, so that everyone may work effectively for the company' and 'Remove barriers that rob the hourly worker of his right to pride of workmanship'.
- In the 1990s TQM was largely supplanted by the ISO 9000 collection of standards.