“High labour turnover is a symptom of weaknesses within an organisation.” Discuss the statement. How can the management in collaboration with different stakeholders reduce the labour turnover? Comment.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
High labour turnover usually signals internal weaknesses such as poor selection, low pay, weak supervision, limited growth and bad working conditions, though some turnover is external, unavoidable or even functional; management can reduce avoidable turnover by working with employees, unions, line managers, government and training institutions on recruitment, pay, careers, welfare and voice.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two tasks: discuss whether high turnover reflects organisational weakness (with avoidable and unavoidable causes) and then explain stakeholder-based measures to reduce it. Measurement and costs strengthen the answer.
Answer outline
Introduction
Labour turnover is the rate at which employees leave and are replaced over a period; a moderate rate is healthy, but a high rate is costly.
Measurement and cost
- Turnover rate = number of employees leaving during the period ÷ average number of employees × 100.
- Costs: recruitment, selection, training, lost output, overtime, lower morale and loss of knowledge; some estimates put the cost at 30% to 200% of the employee's salary.
Why it is a symptom of internal weakness
- Poor recruitment and selection: wrong person-job fit, unrealistic job previews.
- Inadequate pay and benefits relative to market.
- Bad supervision; conflict with management is cited as a predictor of high turnover.
- Lack of training, promotion and career paths.
- Unsafe or unhealthy conditions, excessive hours, poor work-life balance.
- Perceived injustice in appraisal, rewards and discipline.
- Weak communication and absence of voice.
Qualifications
- Unavoidable causes: retirement, death, marriage, migration, illness.
- External pull: booming labour market, competitors poaching.
- Functional turnover of low performers can help; some industries (retail, BPO, seasonal work) have structurally high turnover.
Reducing turnover with stakeholders
- Employees: engagement surveys, exit and stay interviews, suggestion schemes, flexible work.
- Trade unions: agreements on wages, grievance procedure and job security; joint welfare committees.
- Line managers: training in supervision, recognition, mentoring.
- HR: realistic job previews, better selection, competitive pay, career planning, internal job postings.
- Government: social security portability, skill programmes, labour code compliance.
- Educational and training institutions: apprenticeships and industry-linked training to improve fit.
- Families and community: housing, transport, creches, especially for women and migrant workers.
Conclusion
High turnover is best read as a diagnostic signal; analysing its causes and tackling the avoidable ones in partnership with stakeholders turns a costly symptom into an opportunity for organisational improvement.
Examples and data to cite
- Mobley's intermediate linkages model (1977), one of the classic process models of turnover.
- Job embeddedness model (Mitchell and Lee, 2001): links, fit and sacrifice explain why people stay.
- Exit interviews, used to find out why employees leave and what problems they met.
Facts to remember
- Turnover formula: separations ÷ average headcount × 100.
- Voluntary versus involuntary; functional (low performer leaves) versus dysfunctional (high performer leaves) turnover.