Discuss the major difference of Friedman’s restatement of quantity theory of money from the Keynesian demand for money.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Friedman (1956) restated the quantity theory as a theory of the demand for money, treating money as one asset in a portfolio alongside securities and real goods, and held that this demand is relatively stable and depends on a small number of variables; Keynes derived money demand from transactions, precautionary and speculative motives, with an interest sensitive speculative component driven by expectations and a possible liquidity trap, so the two differ on stability, the role of the interest rate, the range of assets and the transmission of monetary policy.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Discuss asks for a structured comparison: set out each theory briefly, then compare point by point (motives, determinants, scale variable, interest elasticity, stability, assets, transmission and policy). A comparison table style in the outline works well.
Answer outline
Introduction
Milton Friedman's 'The Quantity Theory of Money: A Restatement' (1956), in Studies in the Quantity Theory of Money, recast the quantity theory as a theory of the demand for money, set against Keynes's liquidity preference theory (General Theory, 1936).
Keynesian demand for money
- Three motives: transactions and precautionary demand L₁ depend on income; speculative demand L₂ depends inversely on the interest rate.
- Md = L₁(Y) + L₂(r); choice is between money and bonds only.
- Speculative demand rests on how far the current rate diverges from what is considered a fairly safe level, so it shifts with expectations and is unstable.
- At very low rates money demand becomes perfectly elastic (liquidity trap), so monetary policy loses power.
Friedman's restatement
- Money is an asset held in a portfolio alongside securities and real capital; the demand for it can be described as depending on a small number of economic variables.
- Monetarists assume a relatively stable demand for money, so with a stable trend demand a constant rate of money growth yields a steady growth of nominal income.
- An increase in money balances relative to securities and real capital leads holders to spend the surplus on securities, investment goods and consumer goods until portfolios are back in balance.
Major differences
- Range of assets: money against securities, investment goods and consumer goods (Friedman) versus money against bonds (Keynes).
- Role of the interest rate: monetarists treat the expected real rate as fairly stable, so it matters less for money demand; for Keynes the interest rate is the price of money and speculative demand turns on it, with a possible liquidity trap.
- Stability: relatively stable demand function (Friedman) versus a speculative demand subject to unpredictable swings in expectations (Keynes).
- Transmission: direct, as excess money spills over into securities and goods (Friedman), versus indirect, with a larger money stock acting mainly through the interest rate on investment (Keynes).
- Policy: a fixed rule raising the money supply by a set percentage each year (Friedman) versus active fiscal policy, since monetary stimulus cannot raise output in a liquidity trap (Keynesian view).
Conclusion
Friedman restated the quantity theory as a stable demand for money, which made changes in the money supply the main driver of nominal income; Keynes's unstable, interest-elastic demand made money a weaker and less predictable lever.
Examples and data to cite
- Friedman and Schwartz, A Monetary History of the United States, 1867 to 1960, published 1963, which reinterpreted the Great Depression as the result of a major mistake in US monetary policy.
- Unstable money demand and unpredictable velocity led central banks to abandon strategies focused on monetary aggregates during the 1980s and 1990s.
- India amended the RBI Act through the Finance Act, 2016, and notified a 4% inflation target with a band of 2% to 6% in August 2016.
Facts to remember
- Keynes: Md = L₁(Y) + L₂(r).
- Monetarist view: a relatively stable demand for money depending on a few variables; Friedman proposed raising the money supply by a fixed percentage each year (k-percent rule).
- Cambridge equation M = kPY; equation of exchange MV = PY.
- Friedman, 'The Quantity Theory of Money: A Restatement', in Studies in the Quantity Theory of Money, 1956.