Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
“Import tariffs typically result in a net welfare loss for a country”. Do you agree ? Justify your answer by applying an import tariff for a small economy and a large economy.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Do you agree ? Justify
The core of a good answer
Partly: for a small open economy a tariff always lowers national welfare by the two deadweight triangles, but a large economy can gain if its terms of trade gain exceeds those triangles, which is the basis of the optimal tariff; even then world welfare falls and retaliation can wipe out the gain.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for a judgement on a general claim (4 marks) backed by partial equilibrium analysis of a tariff in two cases (6 marks). The answer should agree for the small country, qualify the claim for the large country, and show where each welfare area comes from.
Answer outline
Introduction
A tariff is a tax on imports; its welfare effect is measured as the change in consumer surplus, producer surplus and tariff revenue, and it depends on whether the importing country can influence world prices.
Small economy (price taker)
- World price Pw is given; a specific tariff t raises the domestic price to Pw + t by the full amount of the tariff.
- Domestic output rises and consumption falls, so imports shrink.
- Consumer surplus falls by (a + b + c + d); producer surplus rises by a; government revenue is c = t × new imports.
- Net change = a + c − (a + b + c + d) = −(b + d): b is the production distortion (high cost domestic output replacing cheaper imports) and d the consumption distortion (consumers priced out).
- With a linear demand and supply, deadweight loss = ½ × t × fall in imports = ½ × t² × (slope terms of demand and supply), so the loss rises with the square of the tariff.
Large economy (affects world price)
- The tariff cuts world demand for the good, so the foreign export price falls from Pw to Pw*; the domestic price rises by less than t.
- The country still bears the triangles b + d, but part of the revenue, e = (Pw − Pw*) × new imports, is paid by foreign exporters: a terms of trade gain.
- Net change = e − (b + d); it is positive for small tariffs and negative for large ones.
- The welfare maximising (optimal) tariff equals 1/ε, where ε is the elasticity of foreign export supply; the less elastic foreign supply, the larger the optimal tariff.
- The gain is a transfer from the rest of the world, so world welfare falls by the sum of both countries' triangles.
Qualifications
- Retaliation: an optimal tariff often provokes foreign retaliation, which can leave both countries worse off than under free trade.
- Second best and other arguments (infant industry, revenue, strategic trade, domestic market failures) may justify tariffs, but first best policy is usually a domestic subsidy or tax aimed at the distortion itself.
- Political economy costs: rent seeking and lobbying for protection add to the measured losses.
Conclusion
So the statement holds without exception for a small economy and holds in general for the world, but a large economy can gain from a modest tariff at the expense of its partners, a gain that is fragile because of retaliation.
Examples and data to cite
- The United States Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, signed in June 1930, drew retaliatory tariffs from Canada and other countries; world trade fell by some 66 per cent between 1929 and 1934.
- Tariffs imposed by the United States in 2018 on steel (25 per cent) and aluminium (10 per cent) drew retaliatory tariffs from China, the European Union, Canada and Mexico in 2018; India's retaliatory tariffs took effect in June 2019.
Facts to remember
- Small country tariff: net welfare loss = production distortion + consumption distortion (areas b + d).
- Large country tariff: net effect = terms of trade gain (e) − (b + d).
- Optimal tariff formula: t* = 1/ε, where ε is the foreign export supply elasticity; t* = 0 for a small country (ε infinite).
- The tariff incidence is shared between domestic consumers and foreign producers when the importer is large.