Discuss the major differences between Old and New international trade theories.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Old (classical and Heckscher-Ohlin) theories explain inter-industry trade between dissimilar countries by comparative advantage under constant returns and perfect competition; new trade theory (Krugman and others) explains intra-industry trade between similar countries by increasing returns, product differentiation and imperfect competition, and new new trade theory adds heterogeneous firms.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Discuss" calls for a structured comparison across assumptions, basis of trade, pattern of trade, gains, distribution and policy, with the empirical puzzles that drove the change. A compact comparison under headings works best.
Answer outline
Introduction
Old trade theory covers Ricardo's comparative cost theory (1817) and the Heckscher-Ohlin factor proportions theory; new trade theory grew from the late 1970s and early 1980s work of Krugman, Helpman and others, with strategic trade policy from Brander and Spencer.
Assumptions
- Old: constant returns to scale, perfect competition, homogeneous products, identical technology (H-O) or differing technology (Ricardo).
- New: increasing returns (internal economies of scale), imperfect (monopolistic) competition, differentiated products and consumer love of variety (Dixit-Stiglitz preferences).
Basis and pattern of trade
- Old: differences between countries (labour productivity for Ricardo, factor endowments for H-O) cause trade; predicts inter-industry trade (cloth for wine).
- New: trade can occur even between identical countries because scale economies make each firm specialise in a variety; predicts intra-industry trade (cars for cars) between similar rich countries, matching post war data (Grubel-Lloyd index).
- Old theory leaves the location of specialisation determined by endowments; new theory allows history and accident to decide (path dependence, home market effect).
Gains from trade
- Old: gains from specialisation and exchange according to comparative advantage.
- New: additional gains from larger scale (lower average cost), greater product variety and pro-competitive effects (lower markups).
Distribution
- Old: Stolper-Samuelson theorem: trade raises the real return of the abundant factor and lowers that of the scarce factor, so trade creates losers.
- New: in intra-industry trade, adjustment is within industries, so distributional conflict is milder.
Policy implications
- Old: free trade is optimal for a small country; protection costly.
- New: strategic trade policy (Brander and Spencer, 1983 and 1985) shows that subsidies can shift oligopoly rents from foreign to home firms, for example between two aircraft makers competing for the world market; but a government that shifts rents may invite retaliation.
Empirical drivers and later developments
- Leontief paradox (1953): United States exports were more labour intensive (less capital intensive) than its imports, challenging H-O.
- Growth of trade among similar developed countries and of trade in differentiated manufactures.
- New new trade theory (Melitz, 2003): only the most productive firms export; trade liberalisation reallocates output to them, raising average productivity.
- Krugman's 1991 paper "Increasing Returns and Economic Geography" (Journal of Political Economy) founded the new economic geography, linking trade and location.
Conclusion
The theories are complementary: comparative advantage explains North-South inter-industry trade, while scale economies and firm heterogeneity explain North-North intra-industry trade and the role of large firms.
Examples and data to cite
- Krugman's 1979 paper in the Journal of International Economics explained trade between similar countries by love of variety and economies of scale.
- Melitz, "The Impact of Trade on Intra-Industry Reallocations and Aggregate Industry Productivity", Econometrica, 2003.
- Brander and Spencer (1985): an export subsidy lowers the home firm's costs, it expands output, the rival contracts and rents shift to the home firm.
- Paul Krugman received the 2008 Nobel Prize; the committee said he had deepened understanding of the determinants of trade and the location of economic activity.
Facts to remember
- Ricardo, Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1817): comparative advantage.
- Heckscher and Ohlin: factor proportions theory, first explained by Ohlin in a book published in 1933.
- Leontief paradox: Wassily Leontief, 1953.
- Grubel-Lloyd index measures intra-industry trade: 1 − |X − M| / (X + M).