Explain the effect of a monetary expansion on exchange rate in the short and the long run under perfect capital mobility.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Under flexible rates and perfect capital mobility, a monetary expansion lowers the domestic interest rate, triggers capital outflow and depreciates the currency, raising output in the short run (Mundell-Fleming); with sticky prices the currency initially depreciates more than its long run value (Dornbusch overshooting), and in the long run prices rise in proportion, the nominal exchange rate depreciates in the same proportion and the real exchange rate and output return to their original levels.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer needs the Mundell-Fleming short run mechanism, the Dornbusch dynamics linking short and long run, and long run neutrality; a contrast with fixed exchange rates shows understanding.
Answer outline
Introduction
Perfect capital mobility means domestic and foreign bonds are perfect substitutes, so uncovered interest parity holds: i = i* + expected rate of depreciation; a small open economy takes i* as given.
Short run: Mundell-Fleming, flexible exchange rate
- Money supply rises: LM curve shifts right, putting downward pressure on i below i*.
- Capital flows out; demand for domestic currency falls; the currency depreciates (e, domestic currency per foreign currency, rises).
- Depreciation raises net exports, shifting IS right until i = i* again at higher output.
- Monetary policy is fully effective on output; it works through the exchange rate, not through investment.
Contrast: fixed exchange rate
- The central bank must sell foreign exchange to stop depreciation; money supply contracts back to its original level.
- Monetary policy is ineffective under fixed rates with perfect capital mobility (impossible trinity).
Dornbusch overshooting (1976)
- Asset markets adjust instantly; goods prices adjust slowly.
- With P fixed in the short run, real balances rise and i falls below i*.
- UIP then requires the currency to be expected to appreciate; this is possible only if it first depreciates beyond its new long run level.
- So e jumps above its long run value and then appreciates gradually as prices rise and i returns to i*: exchange rate volatility exceeds that of fundamentals.
Long run
- Prices rise in proportion to the money stock; real money balances return to their initial level.
- Purchasing power parity holds in the long run: the nominal exchange rate depreciates in the same proportion as M and P.
- Real exchange rate, interest rate and output return to the original (natural) levels: money is neutral.
Conclusion
Monetary expansion causes a large immediate depreciation and a temporary output gain; over time prices catch up, the currency partly recovers from its overshoot, and only nominal variables change.
Examples and data to cite
- Rudiger Dornbusch, "Expectations and Exchange Rate Dynamics", Journal of Political Economy, 1976.
- Robert Mundell received the Nobel Prize in 1999 for his analysis of monetary and fiscal policy under different exchange rate regimes and of optimum currency areas.
Facts to remember
- Uncovered interest parity: i = i* + (eᵉ − e)/e.
- Long run neutrality: ΔM/M = ΔP/P = Δe/e; real exchange rate eP*/P unchanged.
- Impossible trinity: a country cannot have a fixed exchange rate, free capital movement and independent monetary policy at the same time.
- Overshooting requires sticky goods prices and flexible asset prices.