Compare Gunnar Myrdal’s “backwash effects” with Simon Kuznets’ “structural transformation” in the context of developing economies.
15 marks · directive: Compare
The core of a good answer
Myrdal's backwash effects describe how growth in a prosperous region or country draws labour and capital away from lagging ones through circular cumulative causation, so market forces widen inequality unless the state intervenes; Kuznets' structural transformation describes the empirical shift of output and employment from agriculture to industry and services that accompanies modern economic growth, with inequality first rising and then falling. One is a theory of divergence, the other a stylised account of change in which convergence eventually follows.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Compare" requires the two ideas side by side: authorship and meaning, mechanism, view of markets, treatment of inequality, policy implications and relevance for developing countries, with points of similarity as well.
Answer outline
Introduction
Myrdal set out circular cumulative causation, including backwash effects, in Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions (1957); Kuznets developed structural transformation in his study of modern economic growth, summarised in Modern Economic Growth: Rate, Structure and Spread (1966).
Myrdal: backwash effects
- Circular cumulative causation: Myrdal held that a change usually calls forth supporting rather than countervailing changes, so the system does not move towards balance and an initial advantage reinforces itself.
- Backwash effects on lagging regions: a region that loses industries sees falling employment, income and demand; firms and workers move out and new investment is depressed, setting off a downward cycle.
- Applied to poor countries, the same "vicious circle of increasing inequalities and poverty" can perpetuate underdevelopment.
- Policy: active state intervention, regional planning and egalitarian reforms.
Kuznets: structural transformation
- Modern economic growth involves a sustained rise in per capita output with large shifts in the structure of output and labour: falling share of agriculture, rising industry and services, urbanisation.
- For Kuznets, growth requires a deep restructuring of the economy, affecting production, employment, income and demographics.
- Inverted U (Kuznets, 1955): inequality rises during early industrialisation as labour moves to the high income modern sector, then falls.
- Kuznets pioneered national income accounting and quantitative economic history; he argued that today's developing countries differ from early industrialisers.
Points of contrast
- Nature: Myrdal's is a theoretical, institutional account of disequilibrium; Kuznets' is empirical and descriptive.
- Inequality: Myrdal sees cumulative divergence without intervention; Kuznets sees a temporary rise followed by decline.
- Markets: Myrdal is sceptical of market forces; Kuznets treats transformation as a largely market driven process with institutional adaptation.
- Unit: Myrdal focuses on regions and countries (spatial); Kuznets on sectors (sectoral).
Points of similarity and relevance
- Both see development as a process of structural change, not just growth of GDP, and both stress non-economic factors.
- In developing countries both are visible: regional divergence within India (backwash) and premature deindustrialisation or slow labour shift from agriculture (incomplete transformation).
- Policy lessons: balanced regional development, infrastructure, human capital and labour intensive manufacturing to make transformation inclusive.
Conclusion
Kuznets describes where development leads; Myrdal warns that markets may not get lagging regions there, so structural transformation must be accompanied by policies that counter backwash effects.
Examples and data to cite
- Agriculture and allied activities employ about 46 per cent of India's workforce but account for about 15 per cent of nominal GDP (Economic Survey 2025-26), showing slow structural transformation.
- Myrdal shared the 1974 Nobel Prize with Hayek; Kuznets won the 1971 Nobel Prize for his empirically founded interpretation of economic growth.
Facts to remember
- Myrdal, Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions (1957); also Asian Drama (1968) on South Asian poverty.
- Kuznets, "Economic Growth and Income Inequality", American Economic Review, 1955.
- Kuznets, Modern Economic Growth: Rate, Structure and Spread (1966).
- Kuznets curve: an inverted U relation between income and inequality; later work notes it fits mainly a short period in post war Europe and the United States.