What are the various approaches to Human Development ? Elaborate Basic Needs Approach.
15 marks · directive: Elaborate
The core of a good answer
Human development has been approached through income growth (trickle down), redistribution with growth, the basic needs approach, Sen's capability approach, the UNDP human development approach and the multidimensional poverty approach; the basic needs approach (ILO, 1976) aims directly at ensuring minimum food, water, shelter and clothing, plus sanitation, health care, education and transport, for all.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part one (8 marks) needs a survey of approaches, each with author, date and core idea. Part two (7 marks) needs the basic needs approach in detail: origin, components, rationale, policy and criticism.
Answer outline
Introduction
Human development is the process of enlarging people's choices and freedoms; approaches differ in what they treat as the end of development and how they measure it.
Approaches to human development
- Income or growth approach: per capita income as the measure; assumes growth trickles down.
- Redistribution with growth (Chenery and others, 1974): research that helped the World Bank move to a more poverty focused approach.
- Basic needs approach: ILO World Employment Conference, 1976.
- Physical Quality of Life Index (Morris D. Morris, for the Overseas Development Council, mid 1970s): basic literacy, infant mortality and life expectancy at age one, averaged equally on a 1 to 100 scale.
- Capability approach (Amartya Sen): development as expansion of capabilities and freedoms; Development as Freedom (1999).
- Human development approach (Mahbub ul Haq, UNDP Human Development Report from 1990): HDI combining health, education and income; inequality adjusted HDI from 2010.
- Multidimensional poverty approach (Global MPI developed by OPHI with UNDP, 2010).
Basic needs approach: origin and meaning
- Grew from dissatisfaction that growth in the 1950s and 1960s did not reduce mass poverty.
- ILO World Employment Conference (1976) proposed meeting basic human needs as the main goal of national and international development policy, endorsed by governments, workers' and employers' groups.
- Paul Streeten, senior adviser to the World Bank (1976 to 1980), helped formulate its basic needs policies; First Things First (1981) was published for the World Bank.
Components
- Minimum private consumption: food (including water), shelter and clothing, the traditional list.
- Essential services added in many modern lists: sanitation, health care, education and transport; different agencies use different lists.
Rationale and policy
- Attacks poverty directly rather than waiting for trickle down; healthy, educated people are also more productive.
- Policies: public provision, targeted programmes, employment generation, redistribution of assets.
- India's Minimum Needs Programme, introduced in the first year of the Fifth Plan (1974 to 1978), is an example.
Criticisms
- Commodity focused: Sen shifted the focus from consumption to capabilities, since equal resources can yield unequal capabilities.
- Programmes built on it may not invest in productive activity that helps a society sustain itself, and they emphasise subsistence over fairness.
- Different agencies use different lists of needs; and the approach has been called consumption oriented, which can suggest that poverty elimination is all too easy.
Conclusion
The basic needs approach shifted development thinking from output to people and was the bridge to Sen's capability approach and the UNDP's human development paradigm.
Examples and data to cite
- First UNDP Human Development Report published in 1990 under Mahbub ul Haq.
- Global Multidimensional Poverty Index launched by OPHI and UNDP in 2010.
- India's Minimum Needs Programme introduced in the first year of the Fifth Five Year Plan (1974 to 1978).
Facts to remember
- ILO World Employment Conference, 1976: meeting basic human needs as the main goal of development policy.
- PQLI: Morris D. Morris, mid 1970s, for the Overseas Development Council.
- HDI: geometric mean of indices for health (life expectancy at birth), education (mean and expected years of schooling) and income (GNI per capita, PPP).
- Amartya Sen: Nobel Prize 1998; Development as Freedom, 1999.