Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
“Commercialization of agriculture in British India was a forced process rather than a natural one.” Elucidate with reference to cash crops like indigo.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Elucidate
The core of a good answer
Commercialisation in British India was driven less by peasants responding to rising prices and more by compulsion: cash revenue demand, indebtedness, advances that tied cultivators to planters and traders, and the needs of British industry; indigo, grown under coercive contracts in Bengal and Bihar, is the clearest case of this forced character.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks the candidate to explain why commercialisation is called 'forced' and to illustrate it with indigo and other cash crops. The answer should contrast 'natural' commercialisation (voluntary, market led, rising incomes and investment) with the colonial pattern (compulsion, debt, export orientation, little gain to the cultivator).
Answer outline
Introduction
From the mid nineteenth century Indian agriculture shifted towards cash crops such as cotton, indigo and opium, which made up most of India's exports by the second quarter of the century, but the shift was shaped by colonial needs rather than by the cultivator's free choice.
Why 'forced'
- Land revenue was fixed in cash and was high and rigid, so peasants had to sell produce, often right after harvest at low prices, to pay the State.
- Indebtedness to moneylenders and traders, who advanced money against the crop, decided what was sown.
- Demand came from British industry and export markets, while railways and ports opened the hinterland to exports.
- Gains went to traders, moneylenders, exporters and planters; the cultivator bore price risk and famine risk.
Indigo as the clearest case
- European planters in Bengal advanced loans (dadan, spelt dadon in some accounts) at very high interest and bound ryots by contract to sow indigo on their own land in place of food crops.
- Planters paid a meagre price, by one account only 2.5 percent of the market price, so the crop was a loss to the peasant, who could remain in debt for life.
- Coercion included mortgages and destruction of the property of those who refused, and planters sued hundreds of peasants for breaking indigo contracts; zamindars, who also gained from indigo, sided with the planters.
- The Indigo Revolt, which arose in Nadia district in 1859 and continued for over a year, was a refusal to grow the crop; Dinabandhu Mitra's play Nil Darpan (1860) depicted the oppression, and an Indigo Commission was set up in 1860.
- In Champaran (Bihar) the tinkathia system forced tenants to grow indigo on part of their land as a condition of tenancy, with barely any payment; Gandhi's Champaran Satyagraha of 1917 led to the dismantling of the system.
Other cash crops and outcomes
- Cotton expansion during the American Civil War (from 1861), financed by moneylenders' advances, was followed by a fall in demand and debt distress in the Deccan, leading to the Deccan Riots of May and June 1875.
- Commercialisation did not bring investment in irrigation or technology by cultivators; it increased differentiation and land transfer to moneylenders.
Conclusion
Commercialisation in colonial India thus widened markets but not peasant welfare; because it was imposed through revenue, debt and coercion, it is better described as forced than natural, and indigo shows this most sharply.
Examples and data to cite
- Indigo Revolt (Nil Bidroha), from 1859, beginning in Nadia district of Bengal.
- Nil Darpan by Dinabandhu Mitra (1860); its English translation was published by Rev. James Long, who was tried and sentenced to imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1,000.
- Indigo Commission, 1860.
- Champaran Satyagraha, 1917, against the tinkathia system.
- Deccan Riots, 1875, after the post American Civil War cotton slump.
Facts to remember
- Dadan (dadon): loan by planters at high interest binding ryots to grow indigo.
- Tinkathia: compulsory indigo on part of a tenant's holding in Champaran as a condition of tenancy.
- A cash revenue demand forced the sale of produce.
- Natural commercialisation implies voluntary response to prices with rising surplus and investment; colonial commercialisation lacked these.