Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Assess the efficacy of land tenurial system reforms in post-Independent India in addressing intermediary abolition.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Assess
The core of a good answer
Abolition of intermediaries was the most successful of India's land reforms: zamindari type tenures were abolished across States and the State came into direct contact with the cultivator, but loopholes in the laws meant that the reform changed ownership far less than it changed the revenue system, and land reform overall succeeded only in pockets.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Assess' calls for a balanced judgement on how far the reform achieved its aim. The answer should describe what intermediary abolition was, the legal and constitutional steps, what it achieved, and where it fell short, with State examples.
Answer outline
Introduction
At Independence much of the country was under zamindari type tenures where intermediaries between the State and the tiller collected rent.
Legal and constitutional route
- Each State passed its own zamindari abolition law, and these laws were delayed by litigation.
- Challenges in courts led to the First Amendment (1951), which added Article 31A to protect agrarian reform laws and, with retrospective effect, Article 31B with the Ninth Schedule to validate 13 enactments relating to zamindari abolition.
Achievements
- The abolition of the zamindari system has been called independent India's most revolutionary land policy; it ended a rent collecting class.
- Tenants of intermediaries became occupancy holders or owners with direct links to the State; land revenue came directly to government.
Limitations
- Landholders often found loopholes in the laws, so land reforms succeeded only in pockets of the country.
- Abolition of intermediaries by itself did not give security to sharecroppers, which is why tenancy regulation was a separate plank of land reform.
Conclusion
Intermediary abolition succeeded as a legal and fiscal reform and laid the base for owner cultivation, but its redistributive impact was limited; tenancy reform and ceilings that were meant to complete it were weak except in States such as Kerala and West Bengal.
Examples and data to cite
- Constitution (First Amendment) Act 1951: Articles 31A and 31B and the Ninth Schedule.
- Kerala, where State administrations carried out the most extensive land, tenancy and agrarian labour wage reforms.
- Operation Barga in West Bengal, launched in 1978, recorded sharecroppers, a later attempt to protect actual tillers.
Facts to remember
- Intermediary: any person between the State and the actual cultivator who collected rent, such as zamindar, jagirdar, inamdar, talukdar.
- Article 31B with the Ninth Schedule protected listed laws from challenge for violating fundamental rights (in I. R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2007, the Supreme Court held that Ninth Schedule laws can be reviewed if they violate fundamental rights or the basic structure).
- Land reforms had four planks: intermediary abolition, tenancy reform, ceilings and consolidation of holdings.