Compare and contrast the economic thoughts of D. R. Gadgil and V. K. R. V. Rao regarding Indian economic planning and development strategies.
15 marks · directive: Compare and contrast
The core of a good answer
Gadgil and Rao shared a commitment to planned and equitable development, but Gadgil approached it from institutions (cooperatives and federal resource sharing) while Rao approached it from measurement and research institutions (national income accounting).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should first set out each thinker's main ideas on planning, then line them up on common themes (role of the State, institutions, measurement, Centre State finance) to show where they agree and where they differ.
Answer outline
Introduction
D. R. Gadgil (1901 to 1971) and V. K. R. V. Rao (1908 to 1991) were among the founders of Indian development economics and both served the Planning Commission.
D. R. Gadgil
- Economic historian ('The Industrial Evolution of India in Recent Times', 1924) and founder director of the Gokhale Institute of Politics and Economics, Pune (1930).
- Saw cooperation as the main institution for rural development; associated with the founding of the Pravara Cooperative Sugar Factory (1949), the first industrial venture in the Asian cooperative sector, and chaired the Maharashtra State Cooperative Bank and the National Federation of Cooperative Banks.
- As Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission (late 1960s to 1971) he shaped the Fourth Plan, which focused on growth with stability and progress towards self reliance.
- Devised the Gadgil formula (1969) for central assistance to State plans: population 60 percent, per capita income 10, tax effort 10, ongoing irrigation and power projects 10, special problems 10.
- The Fourth Plan adopted the objective of correcting the earlier trend of increased concentration of wealth and economic power.
V. K. R. V. Rao
- Pioneer of national income estimation: 'An Essay on India's National Income, 1925 to 29' (1936) and 'The National Income of British India 1931 to 32' (1940); his doctoral thesis was on the national income of British India for 1931 to 1932.
- Served in government as Union Cabinet Minister for Transport and Shipping (1967 to 1969) and for Education and Youth Services (1969 to 1971).
- Institution builder: Director of the Delhi School of Economics (1948 to 1957), Director of the Institute of Economic Growth (1960 to 1963), and Director of the Institute for Social and Economic Change, Bangalore (1972 to 1977); member of the Planning Commission (1963 to 1966).
Comparison
- Common ground: planned development with an active State and concern for equity, both serving the Planning Commission.
- Contrast in method: Gadgil institutional and historical; Rao quantitative and macroeconomic.
- Contrast in emphasis: Gadgil on cooperatives and Centre State resource sharing; Rao on national accounts and statistical measurement.
- Gadgil's legacy is in federal fiscal transfers and cooperative institutions; Rao's in statistics, data systems and research institutions.
Conclusion
Together they complemented the heavy industry focus of the Mahalanobis model: Rao with the data base needed to plan and Gadgil with cooperative institutions and a rule based federal transfer system.
Examples and data to cite
- Gadgil formula, 1969, base for central assistance to States in the Fourth and Fifth Plans; modified later and replaced by the Gadgil Mukherjee formula approved by the National Development Council on 11 October 1990.
- Fourth Five Year Plan objectives: growth with stability and progress towards self reliance.
- V. K. R. V. Rao, 'The National Income of British India 1931 to 32' (1940).
- V. K. R. V. Rao, 'An Essay on India's National Income, 1925 to 29' (1936).
Facts to remember
- Gadgil: Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission till May 1971; died 3 May 1971.
- Rao: Padma Vibhushan 1974; National Professor 1985 to 1990.
- Gadgil Mukherjee formula weights (1990): population 55 percent, per capita income 25, fiscal management 5, special development problems 15.