Trace the trajectory of India’s industrial policy from the Nehruvian model of ‘Mahalanobis Strategy’ to the liberalization era. How has the focus shifted regarding the role of the State and heavy industries?
20 marks · directive: Trace
The core of a good answer
Industrial policy moved from a State led, heavy industry first and import substituting strategy (Second Plan, Industrial Policy Resolution 1956, licensing under IDRA 1951) through a phase of tighter controls in the late 1960s and 1970s and cautious liberalisation in the 1980s, to the 1991 New Industrial Policy, which abolished licensing for all but 18 industries and opened to FDI; the State's role shifted from owner and producer to regulator and facilitator, and the priority shifted from capital goods to competitiveness, manufacturing and infrastructure through private investment.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Trace' requires a chronological account with phases and landmarks; the second part asks for analysis of change in two variables: the role of the State and the place of heavy industry. Later incentive based industrial policy can show where the State still plays a strategic role.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Mahalanobis model (published 1953, applied in the Second Plan 1956 to 1961) held that long run growth depends on the share of investment allocated to the capital goods sector in a closed economy, which gave heavy industry and the public sector the commanding heights.
Phase 1: Nehru Mahalanobis (1948 to 1965)
- Nehru's approach was a mixed economy: a public sector in key industries (steel, iron, coal, power) alongside a private sector.
- Industries (Development and Regulation) Act 1951: licensing of industrial capacity.
- IPR 1956: Schedule A industries (including defence production, metallurgy, mining and transport) exclusively under the State, Schedule B industries majority State owned, the rest open to private enterprise under licensing.
- Public sector steel plants at Bhilai, Durgapur and Rourkela (built with Soviet, British and West German help), and a thrust towards import substitution in basic and capital goods.
Phase 2: Consolidation of controls (1966 to 1979)
- Plan holidays (1966 to 1969) after war, lack of resources, inflation and drought; the rupee was devalued in this period.
- Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act 1969 (approval needed for large houses to expand), FERA 1973 (most foreign owned companies to cut holdings to 40 percent), nationalisation of 14 major banks; reservation of products for small scale units, which peaked at 873 items in 1984.
- Result: 'licence raj', high cost and low productivity industry.
Phase 3: Cautious liberalisation (1980 to 1990)
- Controls were relaxed in stages from the late 1970s; in 1985 the Rajiv Gandhi government delicensed a number of industries.
- Growth rose to about 5.6 percent, but the decade ended in the 1991 balance of payments crisis.
Phase 4: Liberalisation (1991 onwards)
- Statement on Industrial Policy, 24 July 1991: licensing abolished for all but 18 industries; MRTP asset limits removed; automatic approval of FDI up to 51 percent in high priority industries; public sector growth limited to essential infrastructure, goods and services, mineral exploration and defence manufacturing.
- Disinvestment in public sector companies; Competition Act 2002 replaced the MRTP Act.
How the focus shifted
- State: from producer and controller to regulator, facilitator and provider of infrastructure; strategic role remains in defence and in incentive based industrial policy.
- Heavy industry: from public sector led capital goods for self reliance to market determined investment; emphasis on competitiveness, exports and global value chains.
- From import substitution to openness and integration.
Conclusion
The trajectory is not a simple abandonment of the Nehruvian vision: its legacy of a capital goods base and institutions enabled liberalisation, while the State now shapes industry through rules, infrastructure and incentives rather than ownership and licences.
Examples and data to cite
- Second Five Year Plan (1956 to 1961) based on the Mahalanobis model; target growth 4.5 percent, actual 4.27 percent.
- IDRA 1951; MRTP Act 1969; Statement on Industrial Policy, 24 July 1991.
- 1991 crisis: foreign exchange reserves covered under three weeks of imports.
- Competition Act 2002, which replaced the MRTP Act 1969.
Facts to remember
- Mahalanobis model assumptions: closed economy, two sectors, capital as the only scarce factor, non shiftable capital goods.
- IPR 1956: Schedule A industries exclusively for the State; Schedule B industries majority State owned.
- After 1991 compulsory licensing was retained for 18 industries.
- Growth averaged about 3.5 to 4 percent a year from the 1950s to the late 1970s, the so called Hindu rate of growth (term by Raj Krishna).