Discuss the application of laissez-faire theory in colonial India. Why did the nationalist economists criticize this policy as a tool for deindustrialization?
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
In colonial India laissez-faire meant free trade and non intervention in the economy, but it was applied selectively: India was opened to British manufactures and denied tariff protection, while the State intervened freely for British interests (guaranteed railway returns, revenue extraction); nationalist economists therefore saw it not as neutral economics but as a policy that destroyed Indian handicrafts and blocked modern industry.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Discuss' needs an explanation of how laissez-faire was applied, with examples, and of the nationalist critique with names and arguments. A balanced answer may also note the historians' debate on deindustrialisation.
Answer outline
Introduction
Laissez-faire, rooted in Adam Smith and the classical school, holds that markets work best without State interference; Britain imposed free trade on India while Continental Europe and the United States used tariffs of 30 to 70 percent.
How laissez-faire was applied
- After the Charter Act of 1813 ended the East India Company's trade monopoly (except tea and the China trade), the Indian market was opened to British goods, and British textiles inundated it from the 1830s.
- Britain had earlier taxed imported Indian textiles (the Calico Acts, 1685 to 1774), and British cotton manufacturers lobbied for taxes on Indian imports while seeking open access to India: a one way free trade.
- Selective interventionism: a guaranteed return of up to 5 percent to railway companies (from 1849) and heavy land revenue, while in the late 1870s famine a government committed to laissez-faire refused to interfere with grain exports.
Nationalist critique
- Nationalist writers such as M. G. Ranade ('Essays on Indian Economics', 1899) drew on the case, made by Friedrich List, for tariff protection of infant industry.
- Dadabhai Naoroji tied free trade to the drain: opening the country to free trade let foreigners take highly paid jobs, and foreign officials remitted their earnings.
- R. C. Dutt ('The Economic History of India', two volumes, 1902 and 1904) argued that British policy 'discouraged Indian manufactures in the early years of British rule in order to encourage the rising manufactures of England'.
Why a tool of deindustrialisation
- Competition from cheap machine goods without protection caused a severe decline in the handicrafts and handloom sectors; handloom yarn output fell from 419 million pounds in 1850 to 240 million pounds in 1900.
- India changed from an exporter of processed goods into an exporter of raw materials (raw cotton, opium, indigo) and importer of manufactures, the classic colonial pattern.
- By 1870 to 1880 Indian producers supplied only 25 to 45 percent of local textile consumption, and iron production declined even more.
Change and debate
- When Tata Iron and Steel was founded (1907), the Raj promised to buy surplus steel it could not otherwise sell, a sign of selective support.
- Historians debate the scale and timing of deindustrialisation; Amiya Bagchi's work estimated its effect on the employment of hand spinners.
Conclusion
Laissez-faire in India was a policy of free trade for Britain's benefit rather than genuine non intervention; the nationalist critique made the case for protection and planning that shaped India's industrial policy after 1947.
Examples and data to cite
- Charter Act 1813 ended the East India Company's monopoly except for tea and the China trade.
- Late 1870s famine: wheat exports to Britain continued unchecked under a laissez-faire government.
- M. G. Ranade, 'Essays on Indian Economics' (1899); R. C. Dutt, 'The Economic History of India Under Early British Rule' (1902) and 'in the Victorian Age' (1904).
- Calico Acts (1685 to 1774): British tariffs on imported Indian textiles.
Facts to remember
- Laissez-faire: minimal State intervention, free trade, sanctity of contract.
- Railway guarantee system: GIPR incorporated on 1 August 1849 with a guaranteed 5 percent return.
- Infant industry argument: Friedrich List, 'The National System of Political Economy' (1841).
- Deindustrialisation: decline in the share of population and output in manufacturing, especially handicrafts.