Critically examine the impact of the New Economic Policy on the Indian corporate sector. Discuss its effects on privatization, the surge in FDI, and the domestic industry with the entry of multinational corporations.
20 marks · directive: Critically examine; Discuss
The core of a good answer
The New Economic Policy of 1991 freed Indian companies from licensing and MRTP controls, opened sectors to private and foreign capital and exposed firms to competition, which raised investment, productivity and scale; but privatisation was slow, FDI was concentrated in a few sectors and states, and some domestic firms were taken over or squeezed by multinationals.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Critically examine" needs gains and costs with evidence, and a judgement. The three named areas (privatisation, FDI, effect of MNC entry on domestic industry) should each get a section.
Answer outline
Introduction
The 1991 crisis led to the Statement on Industrial Policy (24 July 1991), trade and financial reforms, and a new approach to public enterprises: liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation.
Changes for the corporate sector
- Industrial licensing abolished except for 18 industries; the MRTP asset limit for large houses scrapped.
- The list of industries reserved for the public sector, 17 under Schedule A of the 1956 Resolution, was cut sharply, and public sector growth was limited to key infrastructure, essential goods and services, mineral exploration and defence production.
- Automatic approval for foreign equity up to 51 per cent in priority industries.
- Capital market reform: SEBI, which replaced the Controller of Capital Issues as market regulator, got statutory powers under the SEBI Act, 1992.
Privatisation
- Disinvestment of up to 20 per cent of government equity in selected public sector undertakings announced in July 1991; strategic sales accelerated in 1999 to 2004 (Modern Food Industries to Hindustan Unilever, 2000; Hindustan Zinc to Vedanta, 2001; VSNL to the Tata group, 2002).
- Private entry in telecom, aviation, banking, insurance, power and ports changed market structure.
- Criticism: disinvestment was driven mainly by the need to reduce the fiscal burden and bridge revenue shortfalls, and strategic sales were few until Air India was sold to the Tata group in 2021.
Surge in FDI
- Foreign investment rose from about USD 132 million in 1991 to 92 to about USD 5.3 billion in 1995 to 96.
- FDI equity inflows later reached several billion dollars a year in services alone (USD 7.85 billion into services in 2019 to 20).
- Benefits: capital, technology, management practices, export links (automobiles, electronics, IT).
- Limits: concentration in services and computer software and in a few States; Mauritius and Singapore are among the largest source countries.
MNC entry and domestic industry
- Competition improved quality and choice and pushed Indian firms to restructure.
- Some domestic firms and brands were sold to, or lost market share to, multinationals.
- Domestic industry argued for a level playing field against foreign entrants, a recurring theme in the debate on liberalisation.
- Indian firms also gained from access to foreign capital and technology and from competition that rewarded efficient producers.
Overall assessment
- Productivity gains linked to lower tariffs on final goods and especially on inputs (Topalova and Khandelwal, Review of Economics and Statistics, 2011).
- Weak corporate governance later came to light; the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (in force 28 May 2016) followed.
- Gains concentrated in large firms; MSMEs faced import competition.
Conclusion
The NEP transformed the corporate sector from a protected, licence-bound system into a competitive and globally linked one; its shortcomings lie less in openness than in slow privatisation, weak regulation of concentration and the uneven spread of FDI.
Examples and data to cite
- Statement on Industrial Policy, 24 July 1991: licensing abolished for all but 18 industries, MRTP asset limits removed, automatic approval for foreign equity up to 51 per cent in priority industries.
- SEBI Act, 1992; Competition Act, 2002 replaced the MRTP Act, 1969.
- Foreign investment rose from USD 132 million in 1991 to 92 to USD 5.3 billion in 1995 to 96.
- Corporate tax cut of 2019: 22 per cent for companies not seeking exemptions (from 30 per cent) and 15 per cent for new manufacturing companies (from 25 per cent).
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
Facts to remember
- Licensing retained in 1991 for 18 industries on grounds of security and strategic concerns and social, safety and environmental reasons.
- Schedule A of the 1956 Industrial Policy Resolution listed 17 industries as the exclusive responsibility of the state.
- The rupee was devalued in two steps, on 1 July (about 9 per cent) and 3 July 1991 (about 11 per cent).
- The July 1991 reforms included disinvestment of up to 20 per cent of government equity in selected public sector undertakings.