Examine the implications of the WTO agreements on Indian agriculture with special reference to food security, subsidies and market access.
15 marks · directive: Examine
The core of a good answer
The WTO Agreement on Agriculture has limited India's market access gains and constrains its price support through the de minimis rule calculated on 1986 to 88 prices, which threatens public stockholding for food security; India has protected its policy space through the Bali (2013) interim protection for public stockholding, high bound tariffs and green box spending.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Examine" needs a probe of each named dimension: food security, subsidies (domestic support and export subsidies) and market access, with India's position and outcomes.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Agreement on Agriculture (AoA), in force from 1 January 1995, disciplines agriculture through three pillars: market access, domestic support and export competition.
Food security
- Public stockholding programmes buy food at administered prices; this support counts as trade-distorting domestic support subject to Aggregate Measurement of Support limits.
- Market price support is measured against a fixed external reference price based on 1986 to 1988 (Annex 3, paragraph 9), so inflation alone pushes India's measured support towards the limit.
- Bali Ministerial (December 2013): on an interim basis, public stockholding programmes of developing countries would not be challenged legally; this protection continues until a permanent solution is found, and the Nairobi Ministerial (2015) asked members to make all concerted efforts to agree on one.
- India pressed at Bali for its food subsidies to continue indefinitely; the United States and India reached an agreement on this in November 2014.
Subsidies
- De minimis: product-specific and non-product-specific support up to 5 per cent of the value of production for developed countries and 10 per cent for most developing countries is exempt from reduction (Article 6.4).
- Article 6.2 lets developing countries exempt investment subsidies generally available to agriculture and input subsidies generally available to low-income or resource-poor producers.
- Green box support, government funded and not involving price support, is allowed without limits if it meets the Annex 2 criteria.
- Asymmetry: only 32 members have amber box reduction commitments (AMS entitlements), and critics say the Agreement let rich countries keep subsidising agriculture at home.
- Nairobi (2015) export competition decision: developed countries to remove export subsidies immediately (with a few exceptions), developing countries by 2018, and developing countries may cover marketing and transport costs of farm exports until the end of 2023.
Market access
- Market access pillar: conversion of non-tariff barriers into tariffs (tariffication) and binding of tariffs at ceilings; high bound tariffs leave India policy space.
- Tariff cuts: developed countries 36 per cent on average over six years and developing countries 24 per cent over ten years; least developed countries exempt.
- Indian exports face sanitary and phytosanitary barriers abroad and compete with subsidised produce from developed countries.
- A Special Safeguard Mechanism, letting developing countries raise tariffs temporarily during import surges or price falls, is still under negotiation.
Conclusion
The AoA has not hurt Indian agriculture as much as feared, mainly because of high bound tariffs and the peace clause, but a permanent solution on public stockholding and an updated reference price are essential for food security.
Examples and data to cite
- National Food Security Act, 2013: up to 75 per cent of the rural and 50 per cent of the urban population covered under the Targeted Public Distribution System.
- Bali Ministerial Conference, 3 to 7 December 2013: decision on public stockholding for food security purposes.
- Nairobi Ministerial Conference, December 2015: decision on export competition (WT/MIN(15)/45) and on public stockholding (WT/MIN(15)/44).
- AoA Annex 3, paragraph 9: fixed external reference price based on 1986 to 1988.
Facts to remember
- AoA in force with the WTO on 1 January 1995; three pillars: domestic support, market access and export subsidies.
- Tariff cuts: developed countries 36 per cent average over 6 years, developing countries 24 per cent over 10 years; LDCs exempt.
- De minimis: 5 per cent of value of production for developed countries, 10 per cent for most developing countries.
- Boxes: amber (subject to reduction), blue (amber with production limits, currently no spending limit), green (minimal distortion, exempt).