Discuss the structure of fiscal federalism in India. How have successive Finance Commissions tried to address the vertical and horizontal fiscal imbalances?
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
India's fiscal federalism gives the Union the more buoyant taxes and the States the larger spending duties, creating a vertical imbalance; Finance Commissions under Article 280 correct it by sharing the divisible pool and giving grants, and correct horizontal imbalance through formulas weighted towards poorer and more populous States, with the share for States rising from 32 per cent (Thirteenth) to 42 per cent (Fourteenth) and 41 per cent (Fifteenth, retained by the Sixteenth).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer needs the constitutional structure of taxing and spending powers and transfers, then the methods Finance Commissions have used for vertical and horizontal balance, with criteria and shares.
Answer outline
Introduction
Fiscal federalism concerns the division of taxing powers, spending duties and transfers between levels of government. India's design is centralised in revenue but decentralised in expenditure.
Structure
- Article 246 and the Seventh Schedule: Union List (List I), State List (List II) and Concurrent List (List III) assign subjects and taxes.
- Article 270 provides for taxes levied and distributed between the Union and the States: since the Eightieth Amendment (2000) all Union taxes form a divisible pool except duties under Articles 268, 269 and 269A, surcharges under Article 271 and cesses for specific purposes.
- Article 275 grants to States in need of assistance; Article 282 grants for any public purpose; Article 293 on borrowing by States.
- GST (101st Amendment, 2016; GST from 1 July 2017): GST Council under Article 279A.
- 73rd and 74th Amendments and State Finance Commissions bring local bodies into the system.
Vertical imbalance and Finance Commission response
- The Union holds the more buoyant taxes while States carry large spending responsibilities, which creates the vertical gap.
- Share of States in the divisible pool: 32 per cent (Thirteenth), 42 per cent (Fourteenth, 2015 to 20), 41 per cent (Fifteenth), retained at 41 per cent by the Sixteenth.
- Grants under Article 275 to States in need of assistance, including revenue deficit grants.
- Grants for local bodies and disaster management.
Horizontal imbalance
- Fourteenth FC: income distance 50 per cent, population 1971 17.5, population 2011 10, area 15, forest cover 7.5.
- Fifteenth FC: its terms of reference used 2011 Census population instead of 1971 and provided for rewarding States with good fertility performance.
- Horizontal formulas reward need (income distance, area, population) while trying not to penalise States that have controlled population.
Issues
- Cesses and surcharges, which Article 270 keeps outside the divisible pool, reduce the effective share of States when they grow.
- Southern States objected that use of 2011 Census population would reduce their share.
- Conditional transfers through centrally sponsored schemes reduce States' autonomy.
Conclusion
Finance Commissions have steadily increased untied devolution and used equalising formulas, but the shrinking divisible pool and conditional transfers mean imbalances persist; the Sixteenth Finance Commission, covering five years from 1 April 2026, kept the vertical share at 41 per cent.
Examples and data to cite
- Fourteenth Finance Commission (chair Y. V. Reddy), 2015 to 20: 42 per cent devolution, up from 32 per cent.
- Fourteenth FC horizontal weights: income distance 50, population 1971 17.5, population 2011 10, area 15, forest cover 7.5 (per cent).
- Sixteenth Finance Commission (chair Arvind Panagariya), constituted 31 December 2023, submitted its report on 17 November 2025; the Union accepted its recommendation to retain the vertical share at 41 per cent.
- States were assured compensation for any GST revenue loss for five years from its implementation in July 2017.
Facts to remember
- Article 280: President constitutes a Finance Commission at the expiration of every fifth year or earlier.
- Article 281: Finance Commission recommendations are laid before Parliament with an explanatory memorandum on action taken.
- Vertical imbalance: mismatch between revenue and spending between levels; horizontal imbalance: differences among States.
- Article 270, as substituted by the Eightieth Amendment, 2000, governs sharing of the divisible pool.