A 110/220 V, 1·5 kVA, 50 Hz, single-phase transformer absorbs 150 W power when supplied from a 10 V DC source to its LV side with HV side shorted. It absorbs 10 W at 0·4 p.f. lag when the source voltage is changed to 10 V, 50 Hz AC at the LV side and HV side shorted. It takes 50 W power at 0·2 p.f. lag with rated voltage at LV side and HV side open. Now, if the transformer is to be used at 60 Hz frequency at rated voltage and kVA, then find (i) the maximum efficiency at unity power factor load and (ii) the no-load current, input power and power factor at the LV side with rated voltage.
Neglect skin effect and stray losses. Assume linear magnetic circuit, core loss without hysteresis component and same R/X ratio at both LV and HV side.
10 marks · directive: Find
The core of a good answer
Using the exact equivalent circuit (r₁ = 0·667 Ω, R_eq = 1·6 Ω, X_eq = 3·666 Ω at 50 Hz, R꜀ = 242·7 Ω, X_m = 47·66 Ω), at 60 Hz the pure eddy-current core loss stays about 46·6 W, giving (i) maximum efficiency ≈ 86·4% at unity p.f. (at about 5·39 A, 40% load) and (ii) no-load current ≈ 1·91 A, input ≈ 49·0 W at p.f. ≈ 0·233 lag.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks the candidate to separate winding resistance (DC test), total leakage impedance (AC short-circuit test) and the shunt branch (open-circuit test), and then to rescale reactances and core loss for a change of frequency at the same voltage. Key reasoning: reactances are proportional to f, resistances fixed (no skin effect), and eddy loss alone depends on E² only, not on f.
Answer outline
Introduction
All quantities are referred to the LV side. Rated LV current = 1500/110 = 13·64 A. The DC test gives only the LV winding resistance because a DC source produces no transformer action.
Step 1: LV winding resistance from the DC test
- I = 150/10 = 15 A; r₁ = V/I = 10/15 = 0·6667 Ω
Step 2: Equivalent impedance from the AC short-circuit test (50 Hz)
- I_sc = P/(V cos φ) = 10/(10 × 0·4) = 2·5 A
- Z_eq = 10/2·5 = 4 Ω; R_eq = P/I² = 10/6·25 = 1·6 Ω; X_eq = √(16 − 2·56) = 3·666 Ω
- Same R/X on both sides: x₁ = r₁·X_eq/R_eq = 0·6667 × 2·2913 = 1·5275 Ω; r₂′ = 0·9333 Ω, x₂′ = 2·1385 Ω
Step 3: Shunt branch from the open-circuit test (50 Hz)
- I₀ = 50/(110 × 0·2) = 2·2727 A at −78·46°
- No-load copper loss in r₁ = 2·2727² × 0·6667 = 3·44 W, so core loss = 46·56 W
- E₁ = V − I₀(r₁ + jx₁) = 106·30 V; Y₀ = I₀/E₁ gives R꜀ = 242·7 Ω and X_m = 47·66 Ω
Step 4: Rescale to 60 Hz at 110 V
- x₁ and X_m scale by 60/50 = 1·2: x₁ = 1·833 Ω, X_m = 57·20 Ω; r₁, R_eq unchanged (skin effect neglected)
- Eddy loss ∝ B²f² ∝ E², so R꜀ = 242·7 Ω is unchanged
- I₀ = 110/[(r₁ + jx₁) + (R꜀ ∥ jX_m)] = 1·909 A; E₁ = 106·30 V; core loss = E₁²/R꜀ = 46·56 W
Step 5: (ii) No-load quantities at 60 Hz
- No-load current = 1·909 A (falls from 2·27 A because the magnetising reactance rises by 20%)
- Input power = Re(V·I₀*) = 48·99 W ≈ 49·0 W
- p.f. = 48·99/(110 × 1·909) = 0·233 lag
Step 6: (i) Maximum efficiency at unity p.f.
- Maximum efficiency when load copper loss = core loss: I²R_eq = 46·56 W, so I = √(46·56/1·6) = 5·394 A (LV), i.e. 39·6% of rated current
- Output = 110 × 5·394 × 1 = 593·4 W
- η_max = 593·4/(593·4 + 2 × 46·56) = 0·8644 ≈ 86·4%
Conclusion
At 60 Hz the core loss is practically unchanged (no hysteresis part, same voltage), so maximum efficiency is about 86·4% at roughly 40% of rated kVA, while the no-load current falls to about 1·91 A at 0·233 p.f. lag. If the simplified approach (all 50 W treated as core loss, shunt branch at the terminals) is used, the answers are η_max ≈ 86·0% and I₀ ≈ 1·91 A at 0·238 p.f., close to the exact values.
Examples and data to cite
- A frequency change at constant voltage lowers the flux by the factor 50/60 = 0·833, which is why the magnetising current falls by the same factor.
- The same data pattern (DC resistance test, short-circuit test, open-circuit test) is the standard route to the equivalent circuit in transformer textbooks.
Facts to remember
- Short-circuit test gives R_eq and X_eq; open-circuit test gives R꜀ and X_m.
- Leakage and magnetising reactances are proportional to frequency (linear magnetic circuit).
- Eddy-current loss ∝ B_m²f² ∝ V² for a given core; hysteresis loss ∝ B_mᵏf (absent here).
- Maximum efficiency occurs when variable copper loss equals constant core loss: η_max = S·pf·x/(S·pf·x + 2P_i).