To evaluate the value of resistance, the voltmeter and ammeter methods are used. The voltmeter reads 500 V with a probable error of ± 20 V and the ammeter reads 15 A with probable error of ± 3 A. Find out the probable error in the computed value of resistance.
10 marks · directive: Find
The core of a good answer
R = 500/15 = 33.33 Ω; the relative probable error is √((20/500)² + (3/15)²) = 20.4%, so the probable error in R is about ± 6.8 Ω (R = 33.33 ± 6.8 Ω).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for propagation of probable (random) errors through a quotient R = V/I. For independent probable errors the relative errors combine as the root of the sum of squares, not by simple addition, which gives the limiting (worst-case) error instead.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given V = 500 ± 20 V and I = 15 ± 3 A. Resistance R = V/I. For a product or quotient of independently measured quantities, the probable error is found by combining relative probable errors in quadrature.
Step 1: Computed resistance
- R = V/I = 500/15 = 33.33 Ω
Step 2: Relative probable errors
- rV = 20/500 = 0.04 (4%)
- rI = 3/15 = 0.20 (20%)
Step 3: Combine for a quotient
- rR = √(rV² + rI²) = √(0.0016 + 0.04) = √0.0416 = 0.2040 (20.4%)
Step 4: Absolute probable error
- δR = 0.2040 × 33.33 = ± 6.80 Ω
- R = 33.33 ± 6.80 Ω
Step 5: Comparison with limiting error
- Worst-case (limiting) error = 4% + 20% = 24%, i.e. ± 8.0 Ω
- The probable error (6.8 Ω) is smaller because random errors are unlikely to reach their extremes together
Conclusion
Probable error in R ≈ ± 6.8 Ω (about 20.4%). The ammeter error dominates; improving the ammeter would reduce the uncertainty far more than improving the voltmeter.
Examples and data to cite
- General rule: for X = x1^a · x2^b, the relative probable error is √((a·r1)² + (b·r2)²).
- Here the 20% ammeter uncertainty contributes 0.04 of the 0.0416 sum of squares, about 96% of the variance.
Facts to remember
- Probable error of a function f(x1, x2): Δf = √((∂f/∂x1 · Δx1)² + (∂f/∂x2 · Δx2)²).
- For R = V/I, ∂R/∂V = 1/I and ∂R/∂I = −V/I².
- Limiting error of a product or quotient is the sum of the relative limiting errors.
- Probable error is used for random, independent errors; limiting error for guaranteed accuracy statements of instruments.