An electrodynamometer wattmeter is used for power measurement in a 1-ϕ circuit. The load voltage is 200 V and load current is 20 A at power factor of 0·5 lagging. The wattmeter voltage circuit has a resistance of 5000 Ω and inductance of 60 mH.
Compute the percentage error in the wattmeter reading when pressure coil is connected on the load side. Given that the current coil resistance is 0·4 Ω, inductance is negligible and frequency is 50 Hz. Comment on the result.
20 marks · directive: Compute
The core of a good answer
True power is 2000 W; the wattmeter reads about 2021 W (2013 W from the pressure-coil inductance error plus 8 W pressure-coil loss), an error of about +1.05%; the 0.4 Ω current coil does not enter this connection.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two systematic errors of an electrodynamometer wattmeter must be combined: the pressure-coil inductance error (pressure-coil current lags the voltage by β) and the connection error (with the pressure coil on the load side, the current coil also carries the pressure-coil current, adding the pressure-coil loss V²/Rp). The comment should compare connections.
Answer outline
Introduction
V = 200 V, I = 20 A, cos φ = 0.5 lagging (φ = 60°), Rp = 5000 Ω, Lp = 60 mH, f = 50 Hz, Rc = 0.4 Ω. True power P = VI cos φ = 200 × 20 × 0.5 = 2000 W.
Step 1: Pressure-coil phase angle
- Xp = 2π × 50 × 0.06 = 18.85 Ω
- tan β = Xp/Rp = 18.85/5000 = 0.00377, β = 0.216°
Step 2: Reading due to load current with PC inductance
- W1 = VI cos β cos(φ − β) (scale calibrated on d.c.)
- W1 = 4000 × cos 0.216° × cos 59.784° = 4000 × 1.0000 × 0.5033 = 2013.0 W
- Equivalently W1 = P × (1 + tan φ tan β) approximately = 2000 × (1 + 1.732 × 0.00377) = 2013.1 W
Step 3: Connection error (PC on load side)
- Current coil carries I + Ip, so the meter also registers the pressure-coil loss
- Ip ≈ 200/5000 = 0.04 A; loss = V²/Rp ≈ 200²/5000 = 8.0 W
Step 4: Total reading and error
- Wattmeter reading ≈ 2013.0 + 8.0 = 2021.0 W
- Error = (2021.0 − 2000)/2000 × 100 = +1.05%
- Of this, inductance error ≈ +0.65% and pressure-coil loss ≈ +0.40%
Step 5: Comment
- The meter reads high; the inductance error is large because the load power factor is low (tan φ = 1.732)
- With the current coil on the load side instead, the error would be the current-coil loss I²Rc = 20² × 0.4 = 160 W (8%), so the pressure-coil on load side connection is clearly better for this high-current load
Conclusion
Reading ≈ 2021 W against 2000 W true, an error of about +1.05%; with the pressure coil on the load side the 0.4 Ω current coil resistance plays no part, and this connection is the correct choice for a 20 A load.
Examples and data to cite
- Deflection follows the average of the instantaneous product of the coil currents, so the meter registers active power; any phase error in the pressure-coil current shows up directly in the reading.
- At unity power factor (tan φ = 0) the inductance error vanishes to first order; at low power factor it grows quickly, since the error is about tan φ tan β.
Facts to remember
- Electrodynamometer wattmeter: fixed current coils in series with the load, a moving potential coil across the supply with a high series resistance; on a.c. the deflection follows the average of v × i.
- Reading with PC inductance = VI cos β cos(φ − β); correction factor = cos φ/(cos β cos(φ − β)).
- PC on load side: error = pressure-coil loss V²/Rp; CC on load side: error = current-coil loss I²Rc.
- Pressure-coil phase angle β = tan⁻¹(ωLp/Rp).