Design a PI controller so that a unity feedback system having open loop transfer function G(s)H(s) = 10/((s + 2)(s + 3)) will have the damping ratio of 0·6 and natural frequency of oscillations will be 4 rad/sec. Also determine the characteristic equation of this controller.
20 marks · directive: Design
The core of a good answer
With Gc(s) = Kp + Ki/s, matching the closed-loop characteristic equation s³ + 5s² + (6 + 10Kp)s + 10Ki = 0 to (s² + 4.8s + 16)(s + a) gives a = 0.2, Kp = 1.096 and Ki = 0.32; the characteristic equation is s³ + 5s² + 16.96s + 3.2 = 0.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Pole placement with a PI controller. The PI controller makes the system third order, so the desired complex pair (ζ = 0.6, ωn = 4) is placed exactly and the third real pole is found by matching coefficients. The answer should also comment on the effect of the third pole.
Answer outline
Introduction
Plant G(s) = 10/((s + 2)(s + 3)), unity feedback, controller Gc(s) = Kp + Ki/s = (Kp s + Ki)/s. Desired dominant poles from s² + 2ζωn s + ωn² = s² + 4.8s + 16, i.e. s = −2.4 ± j3.2.
Step 1: Characteristic equation with PI
- 1 + Gc G = 0 gives s(s + 2)(s + 3) + 10(Kp s + Ki) = 0
- s³ + 5s² + (6 + 10Kp)s + 10Ki = 0
Step 2: Desired characteristic polynomial
- (s² + 4.8s + 16)(s + a) = s³ + (4.8 + a)s² + (16 + 4.8a)s + 16a
Step 3: Match coefficients
- s²: 4.8 + a = 5, so a = 0.2
- s¹: 6 + 10Kp = 16 + 4.8 × 0.2 = 16.96, so Kp = 1.096
- s⁰: 10Ki = 16 × 0.2 = 3.2, so Ki = 0.32
Step 4: Controller and characteristic equation
- Gc(s) = 1.096 + 0.32/s = 1.096(s + 0.292)/s
- Characteristic equation: s³ + 5s² + 16.96s + 3.2 = 0
- Roots: s = −2.4 ± j3.2 (ζ = 0.6, ωn = 4 rad/s) and s = −0.2
Step 5: Comment on the third pole
- The PI zero at −0.292 lies near but does not cancel the pole at −0.2
- In the step response this pole leaves a slow term of about −0.33e^(−0.2t), so the response is sluggish (2% settling about 14 s) although the complex poles meet the specification
- Steady-state error to a step is zero because the PI controller makes the loop type 1
Conclusion
Kp = 1.096, Ki = 0.32; closed-loop characteristic equation s³ + 5s² + 16.96s + 3.2 = 0, which contains the required factor s² + 4.8s + 16.
Examples and data to cite
- Check: (s² + 4.8s + 16)(s + 0.2) = s³ + 5s² + 16.96s + 3.2, identical to the PI characteristic equation.
- Without the controller the closed loop s² + 5s + 16 has ωn = 4 but ζ = 0.625 and a steady-state step error of 1/(1 + 10/6) = 0.375; the PI controller removes this error.
Facts to remember
- PI controller: Gc(s) = Kp + Ki/s, adds a pole at the origin and a zero at −Ki/Kp.
- Desired second-order polynomial: s² + 2ζωn s + ωn².
- For a third-order system, the specification is met exactly by placing the complex pair and solving for the third pole.
- Integral action raises the system type by one and removes steady-state error to a step.