In a percentage differential protection scheme, the current in the secondary of the current transformer at one end is 3·4 Amp and the current in the secondary of the current transformer at the other end is 3·0 Amp. The number of turns of the operating coil is 400. Determine the number of turns of the restraining coil for the balance condition. Also explain the requirement of biasing.
10 marks · directive: Determine and explain
The core of a good answer
At balance the operating ampere turns 400 × (3.4 − 3.0) = 160 AT equal the restraining ampere turns N_r × (3.4 + 3.0)/2 = 3.2 N_r, so the restraining coil needs 50 turns; biasing is needed so that the false difference current caused by CT ratio errors, unequal burdens and CT saturation on heavy through faults does not cause false tripping.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The numerical part tests the operating principle of the biased (percentage) differential relay: the operating coil carries the difference current, the centre tapped restraining coil carries the average of the two CT currents, and the relay is on the verge of operating when the two ampere turn values are equal. The explanation part asks why a plain differential relay is not enough.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given I₁ = 3.4 A, I₂ = 3.0 A, N_o = 400 turns. In a biased differential relay the operating coil is connected in the spill (difference) path and the restraining coil is centre tapped so that its effective excitation is N_r(I₁ + I₂)/2.
Step 1: Operating ampere turns
- Operating coil current I_o = I₁ − I₂ = 3.4 − 3.0 = 0.4 A
- Operating AT = N_o I_o = 400 × 0.4 = 160 AT
Step 2: Restraining ampere turns
- Half of the restraining coil carries I₁ and the other half carries I₂
- Restraining AT = (N_r/2)I₁ + (N_r/2)I₂ = N_r (I₁ + I₂)/2 = N_r × 3.2
Step 3: Balance condition
- N_o (I₁ − I₂) = N_r (I₁ + I₂)/2
- 160 = 3.2 N_r
- N_r = 50 turns
Step 4: Bias setting implied
- Slope (percentage bias) = (I₁ − I₂)/((I₁ + I₂)/2) = N_r/N_o = 50/400 = 12.5 %
Why biasing is required
- The relay responds to the difference of the two CT secondary currents, so any error in either CT appears as a false difference (spill) current
- Even an accurate protection CT has a ratio error (for example about 1 % for a Class 1 CT at rated current)
- Protection CTs can be exposed to fault currents of 20 to 30 times rated current, when the core may saturate and accuracy is compromised; the two CTs need not saturate equally
- The burden, mainly the leads between the CT and the relay, also affects CT accuracy, and the two ends rarely have equal burdens
- A plain differential relay with a fixed pick up would therefore operate falsely on a heavy external (through) fault
- With bias, a restraining coil carrying the through current produces restraint torque against the operate torque, so the current needed to operate rises in proportion to the through current: the relay stays stable for external faults and remains sensitive to internal faults at low current
Conclusion
The restraining coil needs 50 turns (bias 12.5 %). Check: 400 × 0.4 = 160 AT and 50 × 3.2 = 160 AT. Biasing keeps the relay stable on through faults without sacrificing sensitivity to internal faults.
Examples and data to cite
- ANSI device numbers list 87 as the differential protective relay, with 87G for generator differential and 87T for transformer differential protection.
- Protection class current transformers must keep their accuracy at overload currents, since they can be exposed to fault currents of 20 to 30 times rated current.
Facts to remember
- Operating coil current = I₁ − I₂ (difference of CT secondary currents).
- Restraining coil effective current = (I₁ + I₂)/2 for a centre tapped restraint coil.
- Relay operates when N_o(I₁ − I₂) > N_r(I₁ + I₂)/2.
- Percentage bias (slope) = N_r/N_o.
- Differential protection responds only to faults within its protected zone, whose boundary is defined by the location of the current transformers.