What is scarification ? List out various impacts and examples of scarification on land.
15 marks · directive: List out
The core of a good answer
In geography scarification is the scarring of the land surface by human excavation, chiefly mining, quarrying, sand and clay extraction and large cuttings, which leaves pits, spoil heaps and bare ground and causes loss of soil, disturbed drainage, pollution, subsidence and loss of habitat; the term is also used for deliberate loosening of the topsoil in forestry and farming.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for a definition followed by a list of impacts with examples. The answer should define the term (and note its other use in forestry), list physical, ecological and social impacts, and give Indian and world examples, ending with reclamation.
Answer outline
Introduction
Scarification (from 'scar') refers to the wounding of the land surface; human excavation is a major agent of landscape change.
Meanings
- Anthropogenic scarification: open-cast mines, quarries, borrow pits, sand mining, road and rail cuttings and their dumps.
- Site preparation in forestry and agriculture: mechanical scratching or loosening of the soil surface to expose mineral soil for seed germination (seed scarification, breaking a seed coat, is a separate botanical use).
Impacts on land
- New landforms: pits, benches, overburden dumps and tailings ponds; loss of original relief.
- Loss of topsoil and fertility; compaction and erosion of bare surfaces; siltation of streams.
- Hydrological change: lowered water tables, disrupted drainage, acid mine drainage and heavy-metal pollution.
- Slope instability and subsidence: dump failures, tailings dam collapses and underground fires.
- Air pollution from dust; loss and fragmentation of forest habitat and wildlife corridors.
- Social effects: displacement, loss of farmland and livelihoods, health problems.
Examples
- Jharia coalfield, Jharkhand: underground fires since 1916, when the first was detected at Bhowrah colliery, and land subsidence such as the 1930 collapse of two collieries.
- Riverbed sand mining, which causes channel bed degradation and erosion.
- Nauru, where phosphate mining has stripped about 80 per cent of the land area, leaving jagged limestone pinnacles up to 15 m high.
- Bingham Canyon copper mine in Utah, a pit over 1,210 m deep.
- Brumadinho tailings dam collapse, Brazil, 25 January 2019.
Remedies
- Topsoil conservation, backfilling and contouring, afforestation of dumps, mine closure plans, regulated sand mining and environmental impact assessment.
Conclusion
Scarification converts productive land into scarred, unstable terrain; reclamation must be planned from the start of extraction, not left to its end.
Examples and data to cite
- Jharia coal fires (since 1916).
- Nauru: about 80 per cent of the island's land area stripped by phosphate mining.
- Brumadinho tailings dam failure, Brazil, 2019.
Facts to remember
- Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 governs mining in India (all minerals except minor and atomic minerals).
- The greatest danger of tailings ponds is dam failure.