Construction of large dams poses serious challenges. Describe the threats and solutions associated with it.
15 marks · directive: Describe
The core of a good answer
Large dams bring irrigation, power and flood control, but they displace people, submerge forests and farmland, trap sediment and nutrients, block fish, emit methane, can trigger earthquakes and carry catastrophic failure risks; careful siting, sediment and flow management, fair rehabilitation and strong dam safety law are the main solutions.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Describe' requires a clear account of the threats (environmental, social, geological and safety) and of the solutions. Indian and world examples, and reference to the World Commission on Dams and India's Dam Safety Act, make the answer specific.
Answer outline
Introduction
Large dams have been central to irrigation, power and flood control but are among the most contested infrastructure.
Social threats
- Displacement: the Three Gorges reservoir forced over a million people to relocate.
- Loss of land, forests and livelihoods; inadequate rehabilitation, as raised by the Narmada Bachao Andolan over Sardar Sarovar.
Environmental threats
- Sediment trapping shortens reservoir life and starves deltas and coasts downstream.
- Nutrient trapping: reservoirs can retain up to 40 per cent of nitrogen, 50 per cent of phosphorus and 60 per cent of silica; the Aswan High Dam reduced nutrients reaching the Nile Delta and sardine (Sardinella) catches fell.
- Dams are barriers to migratory fish and other river animals, and altered flow regimes harm riverine and floodplain ecosystems.
- Methane from anoxic tropical reservoirs; Balbina in Brazil emits about 39,000 tonnes a year.
Geological and safety threats
- Reservoir-triggered seismicity: some geologists attribute the Koyna earthquake of 11 December 1967 to the reservoir, though project officials reject this.
- Tehri dam lies in the Central Himalayan Seismic Gap, a major fault zone, raising concerns about its geological stability.
- Dam failures: Machchhu II at Morbi (11 August 1979) and Banqiao, China (1975), the greatest dam-break disaster to date.
Solutions
- Comprehensive options assessment before building; smaller, run-of-river and decentralised storage where suitable.
- Sediment management: bypass tunnels that divert part of the incoming water and sediment around the dam during floods; catchment area treatment.
- Environmental flows, fish ladders and passes; basin-level planning.
- Fair rehabilitation under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013; benefit sharing.
- Dam safety: seismic monitoring, emergency action plans, environmental impact assessment and public hearings.
Conclusion
Large dams are neither wholly good nor bad; the World Commission on Dams (2000) proposed guidelines for decision-making, and careful siting, sediment and flow management and fair rehabilitation can reduce their costs.
Examples and data to cite
- Koyna earthquake, 11 December 1967, which some geologists link to the reservoir.
- Machchhu-II dam failure, Morbi, Gujarat, 11 August 1979.
- Three Gorges Dam, China: over 1 million people relocated.
- Aswan High Dam, Egypt: reduced nutrient supply to the Nile Delta fishery.
Facts to remember
- World Commission on Dams final report 'Dams and Development: a new framework for decision-making', November 2000.
- Balbina dam in Brazil emits about 39,000 tonnes of methane a year.
- Narmada Bachao Andolan, founded in 1985, opposed the Sardar Sarovar dam over displacement and rehabilitation.
- Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 provides for resettlement and rehabilitation of displaced people.