Answer the following in about 150 words each : “Systematic Geography is essentially analytical and makes generic concepts and Universal Laws.” Elucidate with examples.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Elucidate
The core of a good answer
Systematic geography studies one phenomenon or group of phenomena (landforms, climate, population, cities) across the whole earth surface, so it compares many cases, isolates causes and generalises them into concepts, models and laws; regional geography then uses these generalisations to synthesise particular places.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The statement contrasts the systematic (topical, nomothetic) approach with the regional (chorological, largely idiographic) approach. Elucidate means explaining why systematic geography is analytical and law seeking, with examples of generic concepts and laws from both physical and human geography, and noting the limits of such laws in a 150 word answer.
Answer outline
Introduction
Systematic geography concentrates on a specific geofactor at the global level, while regional geography focuses on the interaction of different cultural and natural geofactors in a specific land or landscape.
Why it is analytical
- It takes one element at a time (relief, climate, soils, vegetation, population, agriculture, settlements) and studies its distribution, origin and processes everywhere it occurs.
- Comparison of many cases allows classification, typology and the search for cause and effect, rather than description of a unique place.
- The two approaches are complementary: systematic study supplies the concepts, regional study applies them to particular places.
Generic concepts and laws (physical)
- Davis's cycle of erosion (The Geographical Cycle, 1899) generalises landform evolution through youth, mature and old stages.
- Such models are generic: they are meant to apply to any landscape where the stated conditions hold, not to one valley.
Generic concepts and laws (human)
- Ravenstein's laws of migration (1885), Christaller's central place theory (1933), von Thunen's agricultural location model (1826), the rank size regularity of city sizes (Auerbach 1913).
- Tobler's first law of geography (1970): everything is related to everything else, but near things are more related than distant things.
- Schaefer's paper Exceptionalism in Geography (1953) set the establishment of morphological laws through scientific inquiry as the aim of the discipline, a landmark of the quantitative revolution.
Limits
- Human behaviour is not fully law bound, so most human geography laws are probabilistic generalisations.
- Hartshorne's concept of areal differentiation held that the differences between places are the core of geography, so regional synthesis remains necessary.
Conclusion
Systematic geography supplies the generic concepts and laws, and regional geography applies them to explain particular places; the two are the analytical and synthetic halves of one discipline.
Examples and data to cite
- Bernhardus Varenius, Geographia Generalis, 1650, an early general treatment of geography.
- W. M. Davis, The Geographical Cycle, 1899.
- W. Christaller, central place theory, 1933.
- F. K. Schaefer, Exceptionalism in Geography: A Methodological Examination, 1953.
- W. Tobler, first law of geography, 1970.
Facts to remember
- Systematic geography concentrates on a specific geofactor at the global level.
- The quantitative revolution of the 1950s and 1960s was a shift from descriptive (idiographic) to empirical law making (nomothetic) geography.
- Regional geography was criticised in the 1950s for descriptiveness and lack of theory.