What are the principles of urban planning ? Critically analyse town planning in India in the post independence period.
20 marks · directive: Critically analyse
The core of a good answer
Urban planning rests on principles of orderly land use zoning, accessibility and circulation, adequate housing and services, open space and environment, efficiency, equity and public participation; post independence India built planned capitals and industrial towns and adopted master plans and national missions, but planning has lagged behind rapid, largely informal urbanisation.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part one: state the principles with the thinkers behind them. Part two: trace post 1947 town planning phases and critically assess achievements and failures with examples and data.
Answer outline
Introduction
Urban planning is the deliberate organisation of land use, infrastructure and services to make cities efficient, healthy, equitable and sustainable.
Principles of urban planning
- Zoning and compatibility of land uses; separation of hazardous industry from housing.
- Hierarchy of roads and public transport.
- Neighbourhood unit (Clarence Perry, 1929): the school at the centre so that a child's walk was about a quarter of a mile.
- Open space and green belts (Ebenezer Howard, To-Morrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform, 1898, revised 1902 as Garden Cities of To-morrow, with a permanent belt of agricultural land).
- Diagnosis before treatment and conservative surgery of old cores (Patrick Geddes, who wrote town planning reports on at least eighteen Indian cities, 1915 to 1919).
- Equity, affordable housing, participation of citizens, flexibility and regional context.
Phase 1: 1947 to 1960s
- Refugee rehabilitation towns: Faridabad, Ulhasnagar, Gandhidham.
- New capital: Chandigarh, first planned by Albert Mayer and then by Le Corbusier with Pierre Jeanneret, Maxwell Fry and Jane Drew; inaugurated as capital of East Punjab in 1953 and made a union territory after the 1966 reorganisation of Punjab.
- Delhi Development Authority (1957) and the first Master Plan for Delhi (1962).
Phase 2: 1970s to 1990s
- Counter magnet and twin towns: Navi Mumbai planned by CIDCO from 1971; National Capital Region Planning Board Act (1985) with counter magnet towns such as Hisar, Kota, Patiala and Gwalior.
- Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act 1976, repealed in 1999.
- 74th Constitutional Amendment (1992): urban local bodies; the Twelfth Schedule includes urban planning including town planning; Metropolitan Planning Committees.
Phase 3: 2005 onwards
- JNNURM (2005) linked funds to reforms.
- Smart Cities Mission (2015), planned for 100 cities.
Critical assessment
- Master plans are slow, rigid and often outdated before notification; large areas grow unplanned.
- Informal settlements and unauthorised colonies dominate peripheries.
- Census towns rose from 1,362 (2001) to 3,894 (2011) without urban governance.
- Planning powers mostly remain with state level development authorities, so the 74th Amendment is weakly implemented.
- Showpiece projects (Chandigarh) are admired but socially exclusive; peri urban sprawl, flooding and congestion show weak environmental planning.
Conclusion
India has rich planning experience but needs decentralised, participatory and regionally integrated planning, with capacity in municipalities, to match an urban population that reached 377 million in 2011 and is rising.
Examples and data to cite
- Chandigarh Capitol Complex, declared a UNESCO World Heritage Site in July 2016 as part of Le Corbusier's works.
- Master Plan for Delhi, 1962.
- 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992.
- Smart Cities Mission, 2015, 100 cities.
Facts to remember
- Urban population of India in 2011: 377.11 million.
- Census towns: 1,362 in 2001 and 3,894 in 2011.
- Twelfth Schedule: an illustrative list of eighteen functions, including urban planning including town planning.