What are the approaches of human development ? Describe in detail the measures for computing human development index.
15 marks · directive: Describe
The core of a good answer
Human development has been approached through income growth, basic needs, human capital, welfare and, above all, Amartya Sen's capability approach; UNDP's Human Development Index operationalises it as the geometric mean of normalised indices of health (life expectancy), education (mean and expected years of schooling) and income (log of GNI per capita, PPP).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
First the conceptual approaches, then the exact HDI method: dimensions, indicators, goalposts, normalisation and aggregation, with a worked example and companion indices. Describe in detail needs the formulas.
Answer outline
Introduction
Human development is the expansion of people's freedoms and choices; the first Human Development Report (1990), led by Mahbub ul Haq, made it measurable through the HDI.
Approaches
- Income or growth approach: development equals rising GDP per capita; criticised because growth may not reach people.
- Basic needs approach (ILO, 1976): food, shelter, health, education for all.
- Human capital approach: education and health as investments in productivity.
- Welfare approach: people as beneficiaries of state provision.
- Capability approach (Amartya Sen; Development as Freedom, 1999): development is expansion of what people are able to be and do; the basis of the HDR.
HDI dimensions and goalposts
- Long and healthy life: life expectancy at birth, minimum 20 years, maximum 85 years.
- Knowledge: expected years of schooling, 0 to 18; mean years of schooling of adults, 0 to 15.
- Decent standard of living: GNI per capita (PPP dollars), minimum 100, maximum 75,000.
Computation
- Dimension index = (actual value minus minimum) / (maximum minus minimum).
- Education index = arithmetic mean of the expected years and mean years indices.
- Income index = (ln GNI minus ln 100) / (ln 75,000 minus ln 100), because income matters less as it rises.
- HDI = (I health x I education x I income)^(1/3), a geometric mean, so poor performance in one dimension is not fully offset by another.
Worked example
- Life expectancy 70 years: (70 minus 20) / 65 = 0.769.
- Expected schooling 12 years and mean schooling 7 years: (12/18 + 7/15) / 2 = 0.567.
- GNI per capita 7,000 dollars: (ln 7,000 minus ln 100) / (ln 75,000 minus ln 100) = 0.642.
- HDI = (0.769 x 0.567 x 0.642)^(1/3) = 0.654.
Companion measures
- Inequality adjusted HDI (2010), Gender Inequality Index (2010), Multidimensional Poverty Index (2010, with Oxford's OPHI), Planetary pressures adjusted HDI.
Conclusion
The HDI is a simple, comparable summary of capability based development, but it omits freedom, inequality and environment, which the companion indices try to capture.
Examples and data to cite
- First Human Development Report, 1990, devised and launched by Mahbub ul Haq.
- The ILO World Employment Conference of 1976 proposed the satisfaction of basic human needs as the overriding objective.
- Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom, 1999.
Facts to remember
- Goalposts: 20 and 85 years; 18 and 15 years of schooling; 100 and 75,000 dollars.
- Income uses natural logarithm; aggregation is geometric mean.