The relationship between El Niño and the Indian monsoon is becoming complex under the conditions of global warming. Critically examine.
20 marks · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
El Niño still tends to weaken the Indian summer monsoon by weakening the Walker circulation, but the link has looked weaker in recent decades because the Indian Ocean Dipole, rapid Indian Ocean warming and changing land-sea contrast now modulate it, so ENSO remains a principal but no longer sufficient predictor.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Critically examine asks for the classical mechanism, evidence that the relationship has changed, the reasons tied to global warming, and a balanced judgement on how far the claim holds. Use drought years, research findings and forecasting practice.
Answer outline
Introduction
ENSO is one of the principal drivers of year to year variability in the Indian summer monsoon, which tends to be weak, with droughts, in El Niño years and strong in La Niña years; the question is whether a warming climate is making this teleconnection less predictable.
Classical relationship
- El Niño conditions are established when the Walker circulation along the equatorial Pacific weakens or reverses and the Hadley circulation strengthens.
- As a result El Niño typically leads to droughts in India, Indonesia and Brazil.
- La Niña years tend to bring particularly strong monsoons.
Evidence that the link is changing
- The ENSO and monsoon link seemed to weaken in recent decades.
- The strong El Niño of 1997 did not cause drought in India; a positive IOD in that year increased monsoon rain.
- So El Niño is not by itself sufficient to forecast a deficient monsoon.
Factors that complicate it under warming
- Indian Ocean Dipole (first identified by Saji and others, 1999): a positive phase with a warmer western and cooler eastern Indian Ocean; it develops in April to May, peaks in October, and a positive IOD often negates the effect of ENSO on the monsoon.
- Different flavours of El Niño: the central Pacific (CP or Modoki) type differs from the classical eastern Pacific event, so the same ENSO index can give different outcomes.
- Rapid warming of the Indian Ocean is weakening the monsoon circulation; future monsoon change depends on a competition between warming land and ocean.
- Warmer air holds more moisture: Roxy and others (2017) found a three-fold rise in widespread extreme rainfall events over central India between 1950 and 2015.
- Since about 2019 some studies find that climate change is increasing the frequency of extreme El Niño events, though there is no scientific consensus on how climate change will affect ENSO.
Critical assessment
- ENSO remains among the most important external drivers, so the claim is not that the link has broken.
- What has grown is the number of interacting factors (IOD, Indian Ocean warming, El Niño type), which makes any single year harder to call.
- For farmers the spatial and temporal distribution of rain (breaks, extremes, onset) matters as much as the seasonal total.
Implications
- Forecasting: in 2010 IMD decided to develop an indigenous model for monsoon prediction; seasonal outlooks now have to weigh ENSO, the IOD and Indian Ocean temperatures together.
- Agriculture and water: contingency crop plans, climate resilient varieties, crop insurance, storage and groundwater management.
Conclusion
The relationship is not broken but conditional: El Niño loads the dice toward a weak monsoon, while a warming Indian Ocean, the IOD and the type of El Niño decide the outcome, so multi-factor forecasting and adaptation are essential.
Examples and data to cite
- 1997: a strong El Niño with no drought in India, as a positive IOD increased monsoon rain.
- 2009 drought in India, the worst since 1972; acute drought of 2002.
- Roxy and others (2017): three-fold rise in widespread extreme rainfall events over central India, 1950 to 2015.
- Saji and others (Nature, 1999): identification of the Indian Ocean Dipole.
Facts to remember
- El Niño conditions: Walker circulation weakens or reverses and the Hadley circulation strengthens.
- Positive IOD: warmer western Indian Ocean, cooler east; often negates the effect of ENSO on the Indian monsoon.
- Central Pacific (Modoki) ENSO is a distinct flavour from the classical eastern Pacific El Niño.
- There is no scientific consensus on how climate change will affect ENSO.