“India’s approach to the Indian Ocean is cooperative rather than coercive.” Critically examine the statement.
10 marks · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
India's Indian Ocean policy is largely cooperative, built on SAGAR (2015), humanitarian assistance, capacity building and multilateral forums, but it is backed by growing naval power, strategic access arrangements and competition with China, and smaller neighbours sometimes read this as hegemony; it is best described as cooperative leadership with a hard-power backstop.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The candidate must test the claim against evidence on both sides: cooperative instruments and actions versus elements that look coercive or are perceived so by littoral states. 'Critically examine' needs a reasoned judgement, ideally linked to the geography of sea lanes, island states and choke points.
Answer outline
Introduction
India sits astride the Indian Ocean's main east to west sea lanes with a long peninsular coastline and island territories in the Bay of Bengal and Arabian Sea; its declared vision, SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region), was announced in Mauritius in March 2015.
Evidence of a cooperative approach
- First responder in disasters: 2004 tsunami relief that reached neighbouring countries within 12 hours, Operation Neer (Male water crisis, December 2014) and Operation Raahat (Yemen, 2015).
- Capacity building: coastal radars and patrol vessels for Maldives, with its radar chain to be networked with India’s, and the Indian-built MCGS Barracuda for the Mauritius coast guard.
- Multilateralism: the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium, an Indian initiative, and IORA.
- Public goods: at least one warship on anti-piracy duty in the Gulf of Aden since October 2008; in January 2024 INS Chennai prevented the hijacking of the Liberian-flagged MV Lila Norfolk.
Elements that appear coercive or hegemonic
- History of intervention: IPKF in Sri Lanka (1987 to 1990) and Operation Cactus in Maldives (1988), which restored President Gayoom's government after a coup attempt.
- Strategic infrastructure in island states raises sovereignty concerns: residents of Agalega (Mauritius) opposed a planned Indian military base.
- Political reactions: amid the 'India Out' campaign in Maldives, India agreed in May 2024 to replace its troops there with Indian technical personnel.
- Naval build-up and Andaman and Nicobar Command, Quad and Malabar exercises are seen by some as bloc politics aimed at China.
Assessment
- India has not established foreign bases in the conventional sense or used force for territorial gain; its tools are mostly assistance, presence and partnership.
- Competition with China's port projects pushes India towards a securitised posture.
- Cooperation is also self-interested: securing sea lanes, energy imports and the Exclusive Economic Zone.
Conclusion
The statement is broadly valid: India prefers consent-based leadership, but its credibility depends on respecting small states' sovereignty and matching promises with timely delivery.
Examples and data to cite
- SAGAR first referred to by the Prime Minister at Port Louis, Mauritius on 12 March 2015.
- A 2015 India and Mauritius memorandum of understanding envisaged developing Agalega, where a 10,000 foot airstrip serves naval surveillance aircraft.
- On 9 May 2024 India confirmed that Indian technical personnel would replace its troops operating aviation platforms in Maldives.
Facts to remember
- India's Exclusive Economic Zone is about 2.3 million sq km.
- Key choke points: Strait of Hormuz, Bab el Mandeb, Strait of Malacca.
- IORA grew out of an initiative formed by South Africa and India and was formally launched in March 1997.