Disaster risk reduction and community resilience are the two pillars that need to be prioritized in the flood prone areas of India. Critically analyse.
10 marks · directive: Critically analyse
The core of a good answer
India's flood policy is shifting from relief and embankments to risk reduction and resilience; disaster risk reduction (forecasting, flood plain zoning, preparedness, resilient infrastructure) and community resilience (local knowledge, volunteers, livelihood and housing adaptation) are indeed the two pillars, but they work only if backed by basin-scale planning, enforcement of land use rules and adequate funding.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The candidate must examine why DRR and community resilience deserve priority in flood-prone areas, show what has been done, and critically assess the gaps, including whether these two pillars are sufficient without structural measures and governance reform.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Rashtriya Barh Ayog (1980) assessed about 40 million hectares of India as flood prone; floods recur, increasingly also as urban and flash floods (Mumbai 2005, Chennai 2015, Kerala 2018).
Why a shift is needed
- Embankments alone have failed or shifted risk: the Kosi breach at Kusaha in August 2008 flooded north Bihar.
- Climate change raises extreme rainfall intensity; encroachment of flood plains and wetlands raises exposure.
- Relief-centric response is costly and repeats every year.
Pillar 1: Disaster risk reduction
- Risk assessment, mapping and flood forecasting.
- Flood plain zoning to keep new settlement out of high-risk areas.
- Resilient infrastructure: raised roads, flood shelters, drainage, restoring wetlands and channels, dam operation rules.
- Dedicated funding for mitigation, which NDMA can recommend; Sendai Framework (2015 to 2030) priorities.
Pillar 2: Community resilience
- Trained community volunteers, village disaster management plans, community early warning, and SHG-led relief.
- Livelihood resilience: flood-tolerant crop varieties, crop insurance and diversification.
Critical analysis
- Strength: local action saves lives in the first hours.
- Gaps: weak enforcement of zoning, poor drainage in cities, inadequate transboundary data sharing on Himalayan rivers, and fragmented responsibilities between water resources and disaster management departments.
- Communities cannot handle basin-scale hazards alone; structural measures and reservoir management still matter.
- Equity: poorest households on embankments and char lands remain most exposed.
Conclusion
DRR and community resilience should be the core of flood management, but they must be integrated with basin-level planning, regulation of flood plains and reliable funding.
Examples and data to cite
- Rashtriya Barh Ayog (1980) estimated the flood-prone area at about 40 million hectares.
- Kosi embankment breach at Kusaha, Nepal on 18 August 2008.
- Kerala floods of August 2018, Chennai floods of November and December 2015, Mumbai deluge of 26 July 2005.
- NDMA Guidelines on Management of Floods.
Facts to remember
- Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015 to 2030 has four priorities: understanding risk, governance, investment in resilience, and preparedness and 'build back better'.
- The Disaster Management Act, 2005 (enacted 23 December 2005) established NDMA and State Disaster Management Authorities.
- Water, including drainage and embankments, is a State List subject (Entry 17, List II), subject to Entry 56 of List I.