Why is it difficult to improve the quality of air during the winter season in the Gangetic plain ? Critically evaluate with suitable examples.
20 marks · directive: Critically evaluate
The core of a good answer
Winter air quality in the Gangetic plain is hard to improve because geography and meteorology (a land-locked basin under the Himalayan wall, temperature inversions, a low mixing height, calm winds and fog) trap emissions from many dispersed sources (vehicles, industry, brick kilns, household biomass, crop residue burning, dust) that cross state boundaries; episodic city-level measures cannot offset this, so only sustained, airshed-wide cuts in emissions work.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The candidate must explain both the natural (physical geography and winter meteorology) and human (emission sources, governance) reasons, illustrate with cities and episodes, and critically evaluate current measures and their limits. A strong answer stresses the airshed concept.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Indo-Gangetic Plain stretches from Punjab to West Bengal; in Delhi, pollution peaks between November and February, when cold weather and stagnant winds trap smoke.
Physical and meteorological factors
- Basin shape: the Himalaya to the north and the peninsular uplands to the south confine air flow; north-westerly winds move pollution down the plain rather than out of it.
- Winter high pressure, clear nights and radiative cooling produce surface temperature inversions; the mixing height falls, keeping pollutants near the ground.
- Low wind speeds and calm conditions reduce horizontal dispersion; fog often forms beneath the inversion when the cool surface layer is humid, adding to smog.
- Absence of rain-out in the dry winter months, unlike the monsoon.
Emission factors that peak or persist in winter
- Crop residue burning in Punjab and Haryana, carried by north-westerly winds and peaking in October, can account for up to 45 percent of Delhi's pollution in the burning season.
- Household burning of wood, dung and refuse for heating and cooking across rural and urban poor households.
- Vehicles and congestion, diesel generators, coal power plants and industries in and around NCR.
- Brick kilns, construction and road dust; firecrackers during Diwali.
Why improvement is difficult
- Transboundary nature: a large share of a city's PM2.5 comes from outside its limits, while mandates are city or state based.
- Livelihood conflict: farmers' economics of residue management, informal industries and brick kilns.
- Enforcement and monitoring gaps in smaller towns; most action is concentrated in Delhi NCR.
- Emergency measures such as construction bans and school closures are short-term and costly.
Measures and their evaluation
- National Clean Air Programme (2019) with city action plans; Graded Response Action Plan for Delhi NCR (approved by the Supreme Court in M. C. Mehta v. Union of India, 2016); Commission for Air Quality Management in NCR (set up in October 2020).
- Upgrading vehicles to BS-VI norms; permanent closure of Badarpur thermal plant (2018); wider use of LPG as household fuel; crop residue management.
- Mixed results: Delhi's AQI still exceeds 400 on the worst days; smog towers were planned, and one was reported out of service in 2023.
- Need: airshed-level governance for the whole plain, crop diversification away from paddy in Punjab, clean household energy use rather than just connections, and electrified public transport.
Conclusion
Winter meteorology cannot be changed, so the only lasting remedy is deep, year-round and region-wide emission cuts coordinated across states rather than episodic city measures.
Examples and data to cite
- Badarpur thermal power station in Delhi closed permanently on 15 October 2018.
- Commission for Air Quality Management in NCR and Adjoining Areas created by ordinance in October 2020.
- National Clean Air Programme launched in 2019, covering 102 cities.
- Graded Response Action Plan approved by the Supreme Court in M. C. Mehta v. Union of India (2016).
- Severe smog episode in Delhi in November 2016 led to school closures and temporary plant shutdowns.
Facts to remember
- Lower mixing heights and calm conditions in winter raise particulate levels.
- A temperature inversion is a layer of warmer air over cooler air; it suppresses vertical mixing and traps pollutants near the ground.
- Under GRAP, 'severe' air quality corresponds to AQI above about 400.