Critically examine the strategic, economic and ecological impacts of the proposed ‘Great Nicobar Project’.
20 marks · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
The Great Nicobar Project, an international container transshipment port at Galathea Bay with a civil-military airport, a township and a power plant, would give India a strategic foothold near the Malacca Strait and a share of the transshipment business now handled by Colombo and Singapore, but it requires diverting about 130 sq km of forest on an island mostly within a biosphere reserve, threatens leatherback turtle nesting, sits on a major seismic fault line, and endangers the Shompen and Nicobarese; its net value depends on scaling and safeguards that are still contested.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The candidate must examine three sets of impacts (strategic, economic, ecological) and weigh them critically, including the social impact on indigenous peoples and the disaster risk. A geographical answer locates the island relative to sea lanes and the Andaman Sea and uses specific features (Galathea Bay, Campbell Bay, Indira Point).
Answer outline
Introduction
Great Nicobar (about 921 sq km), the southernmost island of India with Indira Point at about 6.75 degrees N, lies near the Six Degree Channel and the main route from the Malacca Strait to the west; NITI Aayog proposed a holistic development plan for it in 2021.
Components
- International Container Transshipment Port at Galathea Bay (natural deep draft close to the east to west shipping route).
- Greenfield international airport for dual civil and military use.
- Township and a gas and solar power plant; the island's population, about 8,500 now, is envisaged to grow to about 6.5 lakh by 2050.
Strategic impacts
- Surveillance and power projection over the Malacca Strait, Six Degree Channel and Andaman Sea through which much of East Asia's trade and energy passes.
- Counter to Chinese naval presence and port investments in the Indian Ocean; supports the Andaman and Nicobar Command.
- Strengthens India's role as a net security provider and its Act East connectivity with ASEAN.
Economic impacts
- India's transshipment cargo is largely handled at Colombo, Singapore and Port Klang; a domestic hub would save costs and foreign exchange.
- Jobs, tourism and services; connectivity for the remote islands.
- Concerns: very high capital cost in a remote, logistically difficult location; competition from Colombo and Singapore; uncertain demand projections.
Ecological and social impacts
- Diversion of 130.75 sq km of forest land and about 9.64 lakh trees (2024 government figure), on an island that is mostly part of the Great Nicobar Biosphere Reserve (UNESCO MAB network, 2013).
- Galathea Bay is a nesting site of the giant leatherback turtle, and environmental groups argue that nesting is unlikely to continue if the port is built.
- Compensatory tree planting reported for Haryana's Aravallis cannot replace island rainforest.
- The Shompen (a PVTG of about 229 people in 2011) and Nicobarese face loss of land and exposure to disease; scholars warned in 2024 that this could threaten Shompen survival.
- The island sits on a major seismic fault line; the 2004 earthquake and tsunami caused 4.25 m of subsidence at Indira Point.
Critical assessment
- Strategic logic is strong, but ecological costs are irreversible.
- Critics question the transparency of the environmental appraisal and of tribal consultation.
- Options: phasing and scaling down, strict no-go zones for turtle nesting beaches and Shompen territory, independent monitoring and disaster-resilient design.
Conclusion
The project is strategically valuable, but India should pursue it at a scale and design that keeps the island's ecology and its indigenous peoples intact, since those losses cannot be compensated.
Examples and data to cite
- NITI Aayog proposed the Great Nicobar development plan on 18 January 2021; cost estimated at Rs 75,000 crore (2022), revised to Rs 81,000 crore in 2025.
- Environmental clearance granted in November 2022.
- Great Nicobar Biosphere Reserve included in UNESCO's World Network in 2013.
- In February 2024, 39 genocide scholars warned that the project could destroy the Shompen.
- The Indira Point lighthouse area subsided about 4.25 m in the December 2004 earthquake.
Facts to remember
- Great Nicobar area about 921 sq km; main settlement Campbell Bay; highest point Mount Thullier (642 m).
- Campbell Bay National Park and Galathea National Park, both gazetted in 1992, lie within the biosphere reserve.
- INS Baaz near Campbell Bay is India's southernmost naval air station.
- The Shompen are classified as a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group.